Supreme Court exercise plenary powers to quash POCSO case against man who later married victim The Supreme Court criminal law is a manifestation of the sovereign will of society, but the administration of such law is not divorced from practical realities
The Hindu Logo
Home
News
India
Supreme Court exercise plenary powers to quash POCSO case against man who later married victim
The Supreme Court criminal law is a manifestation of the sovereign will of society, but the administration of such law is not divorced from practical realities
Updated – November 01, 2025 04:28 pm IST – NEW DELHI
PTI
Google Preferred Source
A file image of the Supreme Court of India
A file image of the Supreme Court of India | Photo Credit: The Hindu
In a rare case, the Supreme Court has exercised its plenary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution to quash POCSO proceedings against a man for entering into a sexual relationship with a girl, then a minor, and later marrying her, saying “the crime was not the result of lust but love”.
A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and A.G. Masih noted that the wife (victim) has stated that she was married to the man (convict), and they have a one-year-old boy and are now leading a happy life with the father of the girl, also wishing that the criminal proceedings against her daughter’s husband be brought to an end.
The bench said, “We are conscious of the fact that a crime is not merely a wrong against an individual but against society as a whole. When an offence is committed, it wounds the collective conscience of the society and therefore the society, acting through its elected lawmakers, determines what would be the punishment for such an offence and how an offender should be dealt with, to deter its recurrence.”
It said that criminal law is a manifestation of the sovereign will of society, but the administration of such law is not divorced from practical realities.
“Rendering justice demands a nuanced approach. This court tailors its decisions to the specifics of each case: with firmness and severity wherever necessary and it is merciful when warranted. It is also in the best interest of society to bring a dispute to an end, wherever possible,” the bench said in its October 28 order.
Justice Datta, who penned the verdict on behalf of the bench, said the court needs to balance the competing interests of justice, deterrence, and rehabilitation.
The bench said the founding fathers of the Constitution conferred this court with the extraordinary power to do “complete justice” in proper cases and this constitutional power stands apart from all other powers and is intended to avoid situations of injustice being caused by the rigid application of law.
“Per the law made by the legislature, the appellant having been found guilty of a heinous offence, the proceedings in the present case on the basis of a compromise between the appellant and his wife cannot be quashed. But ignoring the cry of the appellant’s wife for compassion and empathy will not, in our opinion, serve the ends of justice,” it said.
The bench said even the most serious offenders of law do receive justice moderated by compassion from the courts, albeit in appropriate cases, and given the peculiar facts and circumstances here, a balanced approach combining practicality and empathy is necessary.
“The appellant and the victim are not only legally married, they are also in their family way. While considering the offence committed by the appellant punishable under the POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences) Act, we have discerned that the crime was not the result of lust but love.”
“The victim of crime herself has expressed her desire to live a peaceful and stable family life with the appellant, upon whom she is dependent, without the appellant carrying the indelible mark on his forehead of being an offender,” it said.
The top court said the continuation of criminal proceedings and the appellant’s incarceration would only disrupt this familial unit and cause irreparable harm to the victim, the infant child, and the fabric of society itself.
“Accordingly, resting on the foregoing considerations, the developments subsequent to the trial, and in the interest of rendering complete justice, we deem it appropriate to invoke our powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India to quash the criminal proceedings against the appellant, including the conviction and sentence. Ordered accordingly,” it said.
Warning the convict of the consequences, the top court imposed a condition on the man for the relief and said he will not desert his wife and child and also maintain them for the rest of their life with dignity.
“If, in future, there be any default on the appellant’s part and the same is brought to the notice of this court by his wife or their child or the complainant, the consequences may not be too palatable for the appellant,” the bench said and clarified that the order is in the unique circumstances and should not be treated as a precedent for any other case.
Published – November 01, 2025 04:27 pm IST
Related Topics
India / Supreme Court / Delhi / New Delhi
Top News
People ready to cut Congress to size in J.H. bypoll: KTR
Maharashtra woman doctor’s death: Jarange meets her kin, gets them to speak to CM Fadnavis, Dy CM
Trump orders Pentagon to plan military action over Nigeria’s Christian persecution
Beautification drive on for Partnership Summit in Vizag
Bihar JD(U) candidate Anant Singh arrested over Jan Suraaj worker’s death in Mokama
Go to home
Most Popular
Railway Ministry approves Vande Bharat service between Bengaluru and Ernakulam, via Coimbatore
Railway Ministry approves Vande Bharat service between Bengaluru and Ernakulam, via Coimbatore
Bihar Assembly polls: Countdown to oust NDA from State has begun, says Priyanka Gandhi Vadra
Bihar Assembly polls: Countdown to oust NDA from State has begun, says Priyanka Gandhi Vadra
Delhi HC quashes attempt to murder FIR against academician Madhu Kishwar
Delhi HC quashes attempt to murder FIR against academician Madhu Kishwar
MDU official, two sanitation supervisors in Rohtak booked for asking female workers to prove menstruation
MDU official, two sanitation supervisors in Rohtak booked for asking female workers to prove menstruation
HYDRAA pulls down five-storey building on govt land in Miyapur
HYDRAA pulls down five-storey building on govt land in Miyapur
Advertisement
Maharashtra woman doctor’s death: Jarange meets her kin, gets them to speak to CM Fadnavis, Dy CM
Discover
Chennai: Bike-taxi driver arrested for raping woman passenger
Discover
Golden Homes
Golden Opulence @ ₹1.20 Cr, Poonamallee
Read More
Skip
Karur stampede victim’s wife returns ₹20-lakh ‘compensation’ given by Vijay
Discover
Karur stampede: SC asks victim’s kin to approach CBI amid claims of threats
Discover
Launched Phase 2 of Ashiana Vatsalya in Mahindra World city
Ashiana Vatsalya
|
Sponsored
Living in Chennai? Don’t Buy Hearing Aids Before Reading This
hear.com
|
Sponsored
3 BHK Music -Inspired Villas for Sale in Chennai OMR
Isha Symphony Villa
|
Sponsored
Chennai Nurse Made Global Headlines
The Daily Hindi Discussions
|
Sponsored
Gold ETFs and FoFs offer safety, liquidity, and simplicity — all in one.
HDFC Mutual Fund
|
Sponsored
Francesca Orsini: Scholar of the east
The Hindu
Get Minimum Assured Rent of ₹40k/pm or as high as ₹70k/pm
Hiranandani Parks
|
Sponsored
Invest 20k/Month and get 6.6 Cr. Tax free corpus*
Axis Max Life
|
Sponsored
MOST POPULAR
Nepali passenger turned away by Qatar airways, immigration officials had no role to play: MHA
The Hindu
Decode deal making in India
IMP – M&A
|
Sponsored
In Case You Missed It
The danger of an unchecked pre-crime framework
The danger of an unchecked pre-crime framework
New satellite images suggest mass killings persist in Sudan’s El-Fasher
New satellite images suggest mass killings persist in Sudan’s El-Fasher
BJP MP’s remark on ‘removing border fences’ with Bangladesh sparks row in West Bengal
BJP MP’s remark on ‘removing border fences’ with Bangladesh sparks row in West Bengal
West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee to hit the streets in Kolkata against SIR on November 4
West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee to hit the streets in Kolkata against SIR on November 4
Delhi’s winter atmosphere unsuitable for cloud seeding: IIT Delhi report
Delhi’s winter atmosphere unsuitable for cloud seeding: IIT Delhi report
All ethical expectations cannot become Constitutional mandates
All ethical expectations cannot become Constitutional mandates
Delhi HC upholds judgment granting man divorce on grounds of ‘cruelty’
Delhi HC upholds judgment granting man divorce on grounds of ‘cruelty’
Supreme Court raps Centre, States for ‘gross apathy’ over opportunities for transgender persons
Supreme Court raps Centre, States for ‘gross apathy’ over opportunities for transgender persons
Return to frontpage
Google Play
Apple Store
The Hindu
About Us Code of Editorial Values News Archive Sitemap Print Subscription Digital Subscription Subscribe to Newsletters Rss Feeds Readers Editor-Terms of Reference Authors & Contributors Gift Front page
Contact us
Contact Us Social Media Advertise With Us
Group News Sites
Business Line BL on Campus Sportstar Frontline இந்து தமிழ் திசை The Hindu Centre Young World Club The Hindu ePaper Business Line ePaper Crossword + Free Games
Other Products
STEP Images Classifieds – Print Bookstore & Special Publications
Popular Sections
Elections Latest News National News International News Videos Life & Style Food Podcast Showcase
Opinion
Editorial Columns Comment Cartoon Letters Interview Lead
Business
Agri-Business Industry Economy Markets Budget
Sport
Cricket Football Hockey Tennis Athletics Motorsport Races Other Sports
Sci-Tech
Science Technology Health Agriculture Environment Gadgets Internet
States
Andhra Pradesh Karnataka Kerala Tamil Nadu Telangana
Cities
Bengaluru Chennai Coimbatore Delhi Hyderabad Kochi Kolkata Kozhikode Madurai Mangaluru Mumbai Puducherry Thiruvananthapuram Tiruchirapalli Vijayawada Visakhapatnam
Trending on The Hindu
News India News Hyderabad news Bengaluru News Sports, IPL 2025 News Delhi news Live news Entertainment news Sitemap
Trending on Group sites
Stock Market Live Updates India vs Pakistan Live Score, Asia Cup 2025 Final IND vs ENG Test Series Full Results The Hindu Crossword Gold Rate Today Silver Rate Today Arvind Kejriwal Exclusive Interview Editor’s Note: Putting Muslims in their place? Frontline Current Issue
Latest News
A. Sabu not willing to be Senate nominee in V-C search panel
Parties pay tribute to Potti Sriramulu on Andhra Pradesh Formation Day
Bihar polls: the poorest and the richest vie for a place in Assembly
CPI(M) demands action against Chittoor college after student’s bid to ’end life’
64-year-old ailing elephant dies at rehabilitation centre in Tiruchi
