Mere Registration Of Multiple FIRs Insufficient To Invoke Organised Crime Under Section 111 BNS: Madras High Court The Madras High Court has held that the mere registration of multiple FIRs or pendency of investigations cannot constitute continuing unlawful activity under Section 111 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, without satisfying the statutory requirement of prior chargesheets. For petner senior advt Abudu.kumar

Mere Registration Of Multiple FIRs Insufficient To Invoke Organised Crime Under Section 111 BNS: Madras High Court

The Madras High Court has held that the mere registration of multiple FIRs or pendency of investigations cannot constitute continuing unlawful activity under Section 111 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, without satisfying the statutory requirement of prior chargesheets.

Justice N. Ramesh, while granting bail to a 23-year-old student accused of transporting Tapentadol tablets through courier consignments, emphasised that the stringent consequences of invoking organised crime provisions necessitate careful judicial scrutiny of the material relied upon by the prosecution.

The Court was considering a regular bail petition arising from a case registered under Sections 111 and 123 BNS concerning the seizure of 100 Tapentadol tablets from a courier parcel in Vellore.

Examining the scope of Section 111 BNS, Justice Ramesh held that the existence of an organised crime syndicate necessarily depends upon establishing a continuing unlawful activity, as defined under the provision.

The Court explained that the statutory definition requires more than one chargesheet filed within the preceding ten years, of which the competent court has taken cognisance, along with a further instance of such unlawful activity.

“Two first information reports are not two charge-sheets,” the Court observed.

Referring to the Supreme Court’s decisions in State of Maharashtra v. Shiva @ Shivaji Ramaji Sonawane and State of Gujarat v. Sandip Omprakash Gupta, the Court reiterated that continuing unlawful activity is an essential ingredient of organised crime.

Noting that neither of the criminal cases relied upon by the prosecution had resulted in a chargesheet, the Court found no material to attract Section 111 BNS on the record before it.

The Court further observed that there was no material indicating violence, threats, intimidation, coercion or any material benefit obtained by the petitioner.

Justice Ramesh also examined Section 123 BNS, corresponding to Section 328 of the erstwhile Indian Penal Code, and held that the offence requires administration of an intoxicating or stupefying substance to a person, or causing a person to consume it, with the requisite intent or knowledge.

The Court observed that the prosecution had not alleged that the seized tablets were administered to or consumed by any person.

It held that mere possession, transportation, dispatch or sale of tablets, without the element of administration, would not attract Section 123 BNS.

The Court further observed that although a chemical analysis report could establish the nature of the substance, it could not establish administration to any person.

The Court noted that Tapentadol is not included in the Schedule to the NDPS Act and is regulated as a prescription medicine under Schedule H1 of the Drugs Rules, 1945.

Relying on Union of India v. Ashok Kumar Sharma, the Court observed that offences relating to unauthorised sale or distribution of such medicines would, where applicable, fall under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, which prescribes a specific mechanism for prosecution.

“Neither Section 111 nor Section 123 can be invoked to give such a case a gravity that its facts do not carry,” Justice Ramesh held.

The Court cautioned that invoking Section 111 could transform an allegation concerning prescription medicines into an offence punishable with imprisonment ranging from a minimum of five years to life imprisonment, making judicial scrutiny particularly important.

Taking note of the absence of any recovery from the petitioner, the lack of independent material connecting him to the parcel, and the Supreme Court having granted him bail in a connected case, the High Court directed his release on bail subject to conditions.

The Court clarified that if the investigation subsequently revealed material satisfying the statutory requirements of Section 111 BNS, the trial court could consider the same.

The order was passed on November 12, 2026, in Parth Sharma v. State, Crl.O.P. No. 32920 of 2026.

Senior Advocate Abudu Kumar Rajarathinam, instructed by Advocate Aditya Chandramouli, appeared for the petitioner.

 

Government Advocate (Criminal Side) Durai Gunasekaran appeared for the respondent State.

 

You may also like...

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com