Judgement: there are two judgements. We find that the earlier two judgements Dayal and Chandramohan have not been properly considered. We have divided the judgement in various chapters. The textual interpretation has to match the contextual interpretation. No word of a statute can be read in isolation. Article 233 has to be read in whole. Combined reading would reveal that though the constitution under clause 2 provides for qualification for in service candidate it does nor have qualification for in service candidates. 233(2) only provides for qualification. 233 will have to read to give meaning to the first part.
Judgement: there are two judgements. We find that the earlier two judgements Dayal and Chandramohan have not been properly considered. We have divided the judgement in various chapters. The textual interpretation has to match the contextual interpretation. No word of a statute can be read in isolation.
Article 233 has to be read in whole. Combined reading would reveal that though the constitution under clause 2 provides for qualification for in service candidate it does nor have qualification for in service candidates. 233(2) only provides for qualification. 233 will have to read to give meaning to the first part.
