Justice D Bharatha Chakravarthy was hearing a batch of writ petitions and a contempt petition relating to the administration of Nacharammal Kattalai, a religious endowment associated with the Arulmigu Koodalazhagar Temple in Madurai.

[08/06, 13:52] sekarreporter1: https://indianexpress.com/article/legal-news/madras-high-court-movie-like-rs-800-crore-madurai-religious-land-10729282/
[08/06, 13:53] sekarreporter1: Skip To Content
The Indian Express logo
Journalism of Courage
Subscribe

Home
ePaper
Politics
Explained
Opinion
India
Business
Premium
Cities
UPSC
Entertainment
Sports
World
Lifestyle
Tech

NewsLegalMadras High Court rejects trustee’s ‘movie-like’ abduction claim over Rs 800 crore Madurai religious land, orders scrutiny
Madras High Court rejects trustee’s ‘movie-like’ abduction claim over Rs 800 crore Madurai religious land, orders scrutiny
The Madras High Court was hearing a batch of writ petitions and a contempt petition relating to the administration of Nacharammal Kattalai, a religious endowment associated with the Arulmigu Koodalazhagar Temple in Madurai.
Written by: Vineet Upadhyay
7 min read
New Delhi
Jun 8, 2026 01:30 PM IST
Madras High Court Religious Endowment Trustee Kidnapped
The Madras High Court rejected “movie-like” abduction claim of a former trustee to execute a power of attorney to sell religious endowment properties. (Image generated using AI)
Advertisement

Make us preferred source on Google

Religious: Calling a trustee’s explanation a “movie-like defence” that he had been abducted by unidentified persons, taken to the sub-registrar’s office at knifepoint and forced to execute a power of attorney that was later used in transactions involving religious endowment properties, the Madras High Court has ordered scrutiny of rival claimants, recovery of valuable trust lands and protection of assets reportedly worth around Rs 800 crore.

Story continues below this ad

Justice D Bharatha Chakravarthy was hearing a batch of writ petitions and a contempt petition relating to the administration of Nacharammal Kattalai, a religious endowment associated with the Arulmigu Koodalazhagar Temple in Madurai.

“The movie-like defence of the petitioner cannot even be convincingly spoken by him, let alone being believed by anybody else,” the court said on June 1, dismissing a challenge to the removal of a hereditary trustee accused of facilitating the sale of religious endowed properties.

Story continues below this ad

Justice D Bharatha Chakravarty Madras High Court Religious Endowment LandThe Madras High Court said that the records showed that a power of attorney had been executed, and the religious endowed properties were subsequently sold. (File Image, enhanced using AI)
Court criticises ‘movie-like’ defence
Cracking down on a succession battle over a Madurai religious endowment, the court said those involved in alienation or misappropriation of endowment properties cannot be allowed to hold positions of trust.

STORIES YOU MAY LIKE
‘Rs 1,000 cr realtor’ lover, secret Kashi wedding: Inside ‘murder’ of a 6-year-old in Bengaluru
Pannun assassination plot: Nikhil Gupta’s counsel to seek ‘lowest possible’ sentence
Sameera Reddy recalls first meeting with her mother-in-law: ‘Not mera beta…’
The court was particularly critical of former hereditary trustee M Thiruppathi’s “movie-like” explanation that he had been abducted by unidentified persons, taken to the sub-registrar’s office at knifepoint, and forced to execute a power of attorney that was later used in transactions involving endowment properties.

Story continues below this ad

Rejecting the claim as wholly unbelievable, the court said the judge noted that, despite alleging abduction and coercion, the petitioner had not taken action against the alleged abductors.

However, records showed that a power of attorney had been executed, and the endowed properties were subsequently sold through a power agent.

The litigation involved competing claims to hereditary trusteeship, challenges to Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) proceedings, and disputes over the management of endowed properties.

Story continues below. Subscribe to see fewer ads.

Century-old endowment at centre of family feud
The dispute centres on Nacharammal Kattalai, a religious endowment established through a registered deed in 1923 for maintaining a Mandagapadi Mandapam and conducting rituals connected with Lord Kallazhagar’s annual Chithirai festival visit to Vandiyoor in Madurai.

The endowment also involved the maintenance of properties dedicated to religious purposes.

A scheme framed in 1955 and modified in 1967 provided for administration through hereditary trustees representing three family branches, the Senior Muthusamy Pillai branch, the Junior Muthusamy Pillai branch, and the Sundararaja Pillai branch, along with two non-hereditary trustees.

Story continues below. Subscribe to see fewer ads.

Over the decades, rival family members have repeatedly approached courts and the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) authorities over succession and control of the trust.

The latest round of litigation arose after HR&CE authorities initiated steps to appoint trustees, and several claimants challenged the process while asserting competing hereditary rights.

Court upholds removal of hereditary trustee
One of the principal petitions was filed by M Thiruppathi, who had earlier been recognised as hereditary trustee representing the Junior Muthusamy Pillai branch.
Authorities had charged him with involvement in transactions through which endowed properties were allegedly sold to third parties.
Thiruppathi argued that he had been abducted and forced to execute a power of attorney that facilitated the transactions.
He also relied on the fact that he had been discharged from a related criminal case.
The court, however, was not persuaded.
Justice Bharatha Chakravarthy observed that while criminal proceedings require proof beyond a reasonable doubt, departmental proceedings are governed by the standard of preponderance of probabilities.
The court found that the trustee, through a power agent, had participated in transactions that resulted in the sale of endowed property and held that the charges stood proved.
“Trusteeship of an endowment is an office to be discharged by persons of the highest integrity and devotion towards the purpose,” the judge said, adding that attempts to dismantle an endowment through the sale of its assets constituted an extremely serious breach of duty.
The court dismissed the writ petition and imposed costs of Rs 25,000 payable to the Arulmigu Koodalazhagar Temple.
Assets said to be worth Rs 800 crore
A major concern highlighted during the proceedings was the present state of the religious endowment properties.
The court recorded submissions that the properties attached to the Kattalai could be worth around Rs 800 crore.
It noted that revenue records for several properties stood in the names of individuals rather than the endowment itself, raising concerns about the protection of trust assets.
Describing restoration of the endowment’s ownership records as a priority, the court directed authorities to take steps to mutate revenue records in favour of Nacharammal Kattalai.
The judge also rejected suggestions that some lands could be sold because they lacked irrigation facilities.
“Merely because some of the lands are dry lands and do not have irrigation facilities cannot be grounds to sell or otherwise dispose of the property.
Lands are now valuable, and the same is increasing day by day,” the court said.
Transparent process ordered for appointment of trustees
While considering challenges to an HR&CE notification inviting applications for trusteeship, the court acknowledged that hereditary trusteeship ordinarily devolves according to succession and is not a matter of fresh appointment.

Story continues below. Subscribe to see fewer ads.

However, given the multiple rival claims, allegations of irregularities, and disputes over family lineage, the court held that a detailed enquiry was necessary.

The joint commissioner of the HR&CE department, Madurai, has been directed to consider all pending applications and claims in accordance with the law.

Every claimant must file a notarised affidavit acknowledging that the identified properties belong to the endowment, agreeing to the correction of revenue records, and disclosing details of any criminal proceedings.

Story continues below. Subscribe to see fewer ads.

Authorities have also been directed to scrutinise applicants for disqualifications under the HR&CE Act.
Significantly, the court directed that any claimant found to have dealt with or been involved in the misappropriation of endowed properties should have their application rejected.

Encroachments must be removed
The court also issued a series of directions aimed at restoring the religious endowment‘s financial and administrative health.

Once trustees are appointed, they must identify encroachments and bring them to the notice of HR&CE authorities.

Story continues below. Subscribe to see fewer ads.

The assistant commissioner has been directed to initiate proceedings for the eviction of unauthorised occupants and recovery of properties wherever necessary.

The court further ordered the preparation of a complete digital inventory of religious endowment properties and directed that lands be leased in a transparent manner to maximise income for the institution.

Authorities were also asked to recover rent arrears from defaulting tenants and ensure proper administration of movable assets, including bank accounts.

Story continues below. Subscribe to see fewer ads.

Contempt petition closed
The court also disposed of a contempt petition alleging non-compliance with an earlier order concerning the trust‘s administration.

Holding that the circumstances did not disclose wilful disobedience, Justice Bharatha Chakravarthy declined to proceed further.

However, the court clarified that parties would be free to seek contempt action in the future if the fresh directions issued in the judgment were not implemented.

Story continues below. Subscribe to see fewer ads.

Three month deadline for action
To bring an end to the prolonged dispute, the court directed the joint commissioner to complete the process of considering applications and appointing eligible hereditary trustees from the three family branches within three months.

The judgment is expected to have implications beyond the Nacharammal Kattalai dispute, reinforcing judicial concern over the protection of religious endowment properties and underscoring that those entrusted with managing such institutions must meet the highest standards of integrity and accountability.

Curated For You
Telangana man shot dead in ‘fake pizza delivery trap’ in Philadelphia
Telangana man shot dead in ‘fake pizza delivery trap’ in Philadelphia
People are being offered cash, IVF support and housing to have more kids. Why is it not working?
People are being offered cash, IVF support and housing to have more kids. Why is it not working?
After TMC MLAs, MPs may be next: Mamata Banerjee lands in Delhi amid rebellion fears
After TMC MLAs, MPs may be next: Mamata Banerjee lands in Delhi amid rebellion fears
© IE Online Media Services Pvt Ltd
Expand
Vineet Upadhyay
Vineet Upadhyay
follow
Vineet Upadhyay is an Assistant Editor with The Indian Express, where he leads specialized coverage of the Indian judicial system. Expertise Specialized Legal Authority: Vineet has spent the better part of his career analyzing the intricacies of the law. His expertise lies in “demystifying” judgments from the Supreme Court of India, various High Courts, and District Courts. His reporting covers a vast spectrum of legal issues, including: Constitutional & Civil Rights: Reporting on landmark rulings regarding privacy, equality, and state accountability. Criminal Justice & Enforcement: Detailed coverage of high-profile cases involving the Enforcement Directorate (ED), NIA, and POCSO matters. Consumer Rights & Environmental Law: Authoritative pieces on medical negligence compensation, environmental protection (such as the “living person” status of rivers), and labor rights. Over a Decade of Professional Experience: Prior to joining The Indian Express, he served as a Principal Correspondent/Legal Reporter for The Times of India and held significant roles at The New Indian Express. His tenure has seen him report from critical legal hubs, including Delhi and Uttarakhand…. Read More

This article went live on June eighth, twenty twenty-six, at thirty minutes past one in the afternoon.
Tags:
Madras High Court
Madurai
religious
Tip Parents
Woman adopted the most hated dog at the shelter. Weeks later, she screamed OH MY GOD when this happened.
Indians over 65 are switching from hearing aids to this new device.
Recommended by audiologist
Hearing Aids
|
Sponsored
Seniors in Tiruvallur are switching to modern hearing aids
Recommended by audiologist
Hearing Aids
|
Sponsored
The cost of hearing aids in Tiruvallur might surprise you
Recommended by audiologist
Hearing Aids
|
Sponsored
Trade for just ₹20 per order
ICICI Direct
|
Sponsored
Latest News
Home
Newsletters
ePaper
Read in App icon
Read in App
MyExpress icon
MyExpress
Explained icon
Explained

Top Categories
Explained News
Political Pulse
Latest Opinion
Mumbai News
Delhi News
Pune News
Bangalore News
Bollywood News
Health News
India News
Sports News
Lifestyle News
Latest News
Cricket
Tech Reviews
Gadgets
Mobile & Tabs
Food & Wine
Elections
Fitness
Trending News
Stock Analysis
Live Cricket Score
Screen Videos
International Videos
Indian Express Live TV
Screen Awards
Mumbai Weather Today
Bangalore Weather Today
Chennai Weather Today
Pune Weather Today
Ahmedabad Weather Today
Lucknow Weather Today
Chandigarh Weather Today
Lucknow Weather Today
Indore Weather Today
Panaji Weather Today
Manali Weather Today
Kodaikanal Weather Today
Thane Weather Today
Bijapur Weather Today
Gulbarga Weather Today
Malegaon Weather Today
Bhusawal Weather Today
Gurgaon Weather Today
Yavatmal Weather Today
Gangtok Weather Today
Thrissur Weather Today
Udupi Weather Today
Koppal Weather Today
Mumbai Weather Today
Dhule Weather Today
Pune Weather Today
Ooty Weather Today
Panchkula Weather Today
Kulgam Weather Today
Kannur Weather Today
Valparai Weather Today
Hosur Weather Today
Indore Weather Today
Rajouri Weather Today
Kolkata Weather Today
Davanagere Weather Today
Metpally Weather Today
Dharmshala Weather Today
Srinagar Weather Today
Tumkur Weather Today
Balangir Weather Today
Greater Noida Weather Today
Kalaburagi Weather Today
Mahesena Weather Today
Hospet Weather Today
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar Weather
Mira Bhayandar Weather
Ulhasnagar Weather Today
IND vs AFG Scorecard
IND vs AFG Score
LATEST STORIES
Saket building collapse: Delhi HC orders removal of videos blaming judge for tragedy
Madras High Court rejects trustee’s ‘movie-like’ abduction claim over Rs 800 crore Madurai religious land, orders scrutiny
‘Dissolve in the hot chai and ruin it’: Shashi Tharoor strongly reacts to ‘dunkable’ idlis
Teenage girls riding scooter with brother die after being run over by pickup van in Pune
My generation understands technology. We just don’t understand privacy
Lewis Hamilton’s kiss for Kim Kardashian after Monaco podium finish goes viral
Exclusive: Why did South Delhi hotel fire spread so fast? Police to seek IIT-Delhi analysis
INDIA bloc meets in Delhi: Kharge calls for united resistance against ‘Modi government’s ‘misgovernance’
Is India ready for a mandatory shift to electric vehicles by 2028?
Billion-tonne plasma cloud blazing towards Earth: Solar flare expected today
Argument turns violent, 14 shots fired: Gurgaon security officer kills wife and son
How BJP’s third Rajya Sabha candidate in Madhya Pradesh is testing Congress unity
‘Peddi’ tries to be a film about the marginalised. It just gives you the saviour in a new mask
‘I failed IIT, saw her cry’: Google techie shares his Times Square billboard moment with mother, internet applauds
BJP rules out another Rajya Sabha term for HD Deve Gowda, picks M Nagaraja
Leave Iran immediately, India urges in fresh advisory for citizens
Follow Us
Facebook
Twitter
Linkedin
Instagram
Download Apps
Android
iPhone
Newsguard
Newsguard
The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.
Express Group
The Indian Express
ieTamil.com
The Financial Express
ieBangla.com
Loksatta
ieMalayalam.com
Jansatta
ieGujarati.com
inUth
IE Education
The ExpressGroup
Newsletters
26/11 Stories of Strength
Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards
Light House Journalism
Careers
Quick Links
T&C
Privacy Policy
Advertise with Us
Brand Solutions
Contact Us
Subscribe
Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses)
This website follows the DNPA’s code of conduct
CSR
Copyright © 2026 The Indian Express [P] Ltd. All Rights Reserved
Powered by WordPress.com VIP

You may also like...

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com