Justices M Sathyanarayanan and P Rajamanickam HC imposes Rs 15,000 on petitioner for hiding facts

HC imposes Rs 15,000 on petitioner for hiding facts

Madurai: Observing that a litigant is expected to approach the court with clean hands, Madras high court imposed a cost of Rs 15,000 on a man for filing a petition suppressing the fact that a suit was pending with regard to the ownership of a property.

REMOVE ADS

A person named Abbas had filed a petition before HC Madurai bench in 2017 urging a direction to Trichy corporation authorities to provide water connection to his house situated in Muslim Street at Periyapalayam, which he claimed was gifted to him by way of a registered gift deed. He said the connection was disconnected due to lapses of the previous occupants.


The single judge disposed of the plea by directing to provide the water connection after Abbas paid the entire arrears. Challenging the order, S Asak Basha filed the present appeal in 2018. Basha said through his counsel that Abbas had filed a suit before the Trichy district munsif court with regard to the ownership of the property and this was suppressed by Abbas while filing his petition in 2017.

NEWS IN
BRIEF

Your one-minute Citynews catch up

Eye on China: Govt mulls duty hike on textiles, cameras, laptops

The government is considering increasing customs duty on close to 20 product segments including laptops, cameras, textiles and aluminium goods, while placing some steel items under import licensing, as part of its latest move to restrict imports from China. The issue is now before finance ministry, which had earlier spurned the proposal from commerce ministry, said sources.

Sachin Pilot cancels flight from Congress after meeting Rahul, Priyanka

Sachin Pilot met Congress leaders Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and rolled back his rebellion on the assurance that his grievances would be “redressed” even though the terms of the peace deal remain to be worked out in detail. “Pilot has committed to working in the interest of Congress and the Congress government in Rajasthan,” the party said.

Pranab Mukherjee put on ventilator after brain clot surgery

Former President Pranab Mukherjee was put on ventilator support on Monday after undergoing surgery for removal of a clot in his brain. He has also tested positive for Covid-19. “I request the people who came in contact with me in the last week, to please self-isolate and get tested for Covid-19,” Mukherjee tweeted. Sources said the former President is ‘critical’.

As questions arise over 3 killed in J&K encounter, Army orders probe

Over 20 days after three unknown “terrorists” were eliminated in an encounter in Shopian (J&K), family members of three labourers in Rajouri district have filed missing reports. After netizens urged the Army to ascertain the identity of the men killed on July 18, Army sources confirmed to TOI on Monday that the bodies would be exhumed for investigation and DNA testing.

29% of world’s new Covid cases in India

The country’s share in global Covid-19 numbers hit a new peak on Sunday, when 29% of all new cases worldwide and 21% of all deaths from the virus reported on the day were from India. India has the highest share of global cases so far this month, with a cumulative count of 5,19,351 cases in the first nine days of August. The death toll from the virus crossed 45,000 on Monday.

SC to decide if Prashant Bhushan committed contempt

The Supreme Court on Monday decided to scrutinise activist-advocate Prashant Bhushan’s 2009 allegation that “half of the 16 former CJIs were corrupt” to determine whether it would amount to contempt of court. In a single-sentence order, the Bench said that before reaching any finding, the matter is required to be heard. The next hearing will be on August 17.

GO TO BRIEFS


Hearing the appeal, a division bench of Justices M Sathyanarayanan and P Rajamanickam observed that the pendency of the civil suit may have a bearing on the request for water connection, but it was not disclosed by Abbas in his petition. Though Abbas in his writ petition claimed absolute ownership of the property, he cannot make such an averment until he gets declaratory relief in the pending suit. Hence, the judges allowed the appeal filed by Basha and set aside the order of a single judge.

Since Abbas had deliberately suppressed the finding of the suit and made the court to pass some orders in his favour, the judges imposed a cost of Rs 15,000 on him payable to additional registrar general (in-charge) / registrar (judicial) for purchasing necessary equipment for the court dispensary.

You may also like...