Justice B Pugalendhi, allowing a petition filed by Deva Vijay, held that the couple had been in a voluntary relationship for nearly nine years and that continuing criminal prosecution would amount to an abuse of process. The case stemmed from a complaint filed by the woman in 2025, alleging

NDTV News
Live TV
Latest
India
Videos
Beeps
World
Lifestyle
Good Times
Bihar Polls
Movies
Podcast
Live Blogs
Top Deals
Auto
Education
Offbeat
Opinion
Cities
Trends
Food
Tech
Weather
Health
TV Schedule
Photos
Games
18 Members Of Hyderabad Family – 3 Generations – Killed In Saudi Bus CrashIndia News
18 Members Of Hyderabad Family – 3 Generations – Killed In Saudi Bus Crash
Before Delhi Blast, Terrorists Planned Hamas-Like Attack Using DronesIndia News
Before Delhi Blast, Terrorists Planned Hamas-Like Attack Using Drones
‘Unelected, Illegal Regime’s Sham Of A Verdict’: Sheikh Hasina’s SonWorld News
‘Unelected, Illegal Regime’s Sham Of A Verdict’: Sheikh Hasina’s Son
India-US Trade Deal ‘Nearing Closure,’ Set To Address Tariff Issue: OfficialIndia News
India-US Trade Deal ‘Nearing Closure,’ Set To Address Tariff Issue: Official
Trump Unveils “FIFA Visas” For 2026 World Cup Ticket HoldersWorld News
Trump Unveils “FIFA Visas” For 2026 World Cup Ticket Holders
‘Parasocial’ Crowned Cambridge Dictionary Word Of 2025: What It MeansWorld News
‘Parasocial’ Crowned Cambridge Dictionary Word Of 2025: What It Means
“Yunus Wants Civil War”: Sheikh Hasina’s Aide After Death Penalty VerdictWorld News
“Yunus Wants Civil War”: Sheikh Hasina’s Aide After Death Penalty Verdict
In BJP’s ‘Mission Bengal’, Different Strategies To Be Anchored By Top LeadersIndia News
In BJP’s ‘Mission Bengal’, Different Strategies To Be Anchored By Top Leaders
‘Ask An Astrologer’: DK Shivakumar On Karnataka Leadership Change QueryIndia News
‘Ask An Astrologer’: DK Shivakumar On Karnataka Leadership Change Query
Explained: ‘D-Voters’ In Assam’s Special Summary Revision Before ElectionsIndia News
Explained: ‘D-Voters’ In Assam’s Special Summary Revision Before Elections
After Mehbooba Mufti, Congress Leader Links Delhi Blast To “Injustice” In J&KIndia News
After Mehbooba Mufti, Congress Leader Links Delhi Blast To “Injustice” In J&K
“Biryani”, “Daawat”: Codes Used By White Collar Terror Module On TelegramIndia News
“Biryani”, “Daawat”: Codes Used By White Collar Terror Module On Telegram
Terror Accused Arrested From Delhi Helped Suicide Bomber In Making ExplosivesIndia News
Terror Accused Arrested From Delhi Helped Suicide Bomber In Making Explosives
“Didn’t Work In 1971, Won’t Now”: Sheikh Hasina Aide Calls Trial “Scripted”World News
“Didn’t Work In 1971, Won’t Now”: Sheikh Hasina Aide Calls Trial “Scripted”
Dhaka Courtroom Erupts In Claps, Cheers As Sheikh Hasina Gets Death PenaltyWorld News
Dhaka Courtroom Erupts In Claps, Cheers As Sheikh Hasina Gets Death Penalty
News
India News
Every Failed Relationship Cannot Be Criminalised: Tamil Nadu Court
Read In AppEvery Failed Relationship Cannot Be Criminalised: Tamil Nadu CourtThe judge remarked on the “growing tendency” of invoking rape provisions when relationships turn sour, saying that every failed relationship cannot be given a “colour of criminality”.
Reported by:
J Sam Daniel Stalin
Edited by:
Akash Majumder
India News
Nov 17, 2025 23:46 pm IST
Published On
Nov 17, 2025 23:46 pm IST
Last Updated On
Nov 17, 2025 23:46 pm IST
Read Time:
2 mins
Every Failed Relationship Cannot Be Criminalised: Tamil Nadu Court
The case stemmed from a complaint filed by the woman in 2025.
Reiterating that consensual long-term relationships cannot be retrospectively criminalised, the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court has quashed rape proceedings against a man accused of having sexual intercourse with a woman on the alleged false promise of marriage.

Justice B Pugalendhi, allowing a petition filed by Deva Vijay, held that the couple had been in a voluntary relationship for nearly nine years and that continuing criminal prosecution would amount to an abuse of process. The case stemmed from a complaint filed by the woman in 2025, alleging that she had consented to sexual relations since 2015, believing the petitioner would marry her, and that he attempted to marry someone else later.

The Court noted that the relationship, which continued till 2024, was clearly consensual, sustained without protest over several years, and involved two educated adults who “consciously entered into a relationship of intimacy”. The judge emphasised that “private discord arising from consensual acts cannot be converted into criminal misconduct”.

Justice Pugalendhi relied on a series of Supreme Court rulings, including ‘Pramod Suryabhan Pawar’, ‘Deepak Gulati’, ‘Biswajyoti Chatterjee’, and ‘Mahesh Damu Khare’, which draw a clear distinction between a mere breach of promise to marry and a false promise made with mala fide intent from the very beginning. The High Court observed that there was nothing on record to suggest that the petitioner had, at the inception, made a deceptive promise solely to induce the woman into a physical relationship.

The judge also remarked on the “growing tendency” of invoking rape provisions when relationships turn sour, saying that every failed relationship cannot be given a “colour of criminality”.

Holding that the sustained intimacy over nine years made the allegation a misconception of consent “implausible”, the Court quashed the proceedings pending before the Judicial Magistrate, Valliyur, and closed all connected petitions.

Featured Video Of The Day

Siddaramaiah-DK Shivakumar Status Quo To Continue In Karnataka?
Related Stories
India News
RG Kar Victim’s Father Alleges CBI Chargesheet Delay, Administrative Lapses
India News
“More Or Less Consensual”: Thane Court Acquits Man In Minor’s Rape Case
India News
RG Kar Victim’s Mother Says ‘CBI Doing Everything To Protect Real Culprits’
India News
Court Cautions Against Criminalising Consensual Relationships That Turn Sour
India News
Lawyer Calls Woman To Discuss Assault Case Settlement, Rapes Her
Topics mentioned in this article
Madras High Court
Rape Case
False Promise Of Marriage
Malayalam Actor Meera Vasudevan Announces Third Divorce
Discover
“I Don’t Believe In God”: SS Rajamouli Receives Backlash For Religious Statement At Varanasi Event
Discover
Open ICICI 3-in-1 Account
ICICI Direct – Get Margin Trading Facility @9.65% p.a.
Read More
Skip
Kushboo Sundar Slams Trolls After Sundar C Backs Out Of Thalaivar 173
Discover
Dhanush To Direct Rajnikanth’s Thalaivar 173 After Sundar C’s Exit: Report
Discover
Good News: Students Can Now Save Big
All Students Unite: Travel With Your Friends And Save 10% With Student Fare
Students Save More With IndiGo
|
Sponsored
Your 5-Day Hair Growth Ritual
Begin your simple 5-day routine and watch your hair look fuller, healthier, and stronger.
Youneek Pro Science
|
Sponsored
ATH Palladium: Defence Colony, Ekkattuthangal
Close to Ekkattuthangal Metro. Near DLF IT Park & Airport.
Asset Tree Homes
|
Sponsored
Cat® Central App – Cat® Central App: Power at Your Fingertips.
Cat® Customer Value Agreements
|
Sponsored
Your Child’s Confidence Journey Starts Here
Help your child grow into a bold, confident speaker with PlanetSpark.
PlanetSpark
|
Sponsored
Everyone Said Blueberries Won’t Grow Here
An Indian balcony gardener used one seed trick to prove everyone wrong.
Plant Heaven
|
Sponsored
3 Lakh+ Have Transformed Their Smile
Don’t settle. Fix your smile like 3L+ others. Backed by 2K+ dentists, FDA-cleared, starts ₹2485/month.
Toothsi by MakeO
|
Sponsored
About Us
Advertise
EPG Services
Channels
Disclaimer
Feedback
Investors
Redressals
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Partner Content
Archives
This website follows the DNPA Code of Ethics
© Copyright NDTV Convergence Limited 2025. All rights reserved.
NDTV News
Edition
INDIA
INDIA
World
World
Search for News, Photos and Videos
Get App for Better Experience
Install Now
choose your destinationHindiMarathiMPCGRajasthanNews Updates
Live TV
India
Spotlight
Good Times
Beeps
Latest
Video
Podcast
Lifestyle
Elections
Profit
Movies
Cricket
Cities
Featured
Notifications
Opinion
Web Stories
Trends
Feature
More Links
Offbeat
Science
People
South
Education
Tech
Food
Sports
Health
Photos
TV Schedule
Toolbox
Follow Us On
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Linkedin
Youtube
Whatsapp
Threads
Snapchat
Listen to the latest songs, only on JioSaavn.com

MTech in Data Science & AI without quitting your job
Weekend classroom program for working professionals with career assistance
PES University
|
Sponsored
Plan Your Vacation to Lakshadweep with Cordelia Cruises
Cruise to Lakshadweep with Cordelia Cruises. Book now & avail deals
Cordelia Cruises
|
Sponsored
TVS Brings Premium Low-Density Living to OMR
TVS Verde Vista offers 2 & 3 BHK low-rise residences on OMR Padur. Surrounded by greenery, private lake, and large clubhouse. Homes start at ₹72.5 Lakh*.
TVS Verde Vista
|
Sponsored
Term plan – 0% GST on premiums
ICICI Pru Life Insurance Plan
|
Sponsored
Tiruvallur – Born before 1975? You’re eligible for trial of German hearing aid.
Hear.com
|
Sponsored
Earn Upto 5k Daily By This Method of Intraday Trading
TradeWise
|
Sponsored
Ultimate ₹399 Combo Deal.
Vokka Perfumes
|
Sponsored