NewsSC upholds Benami Act attachment during IBC moratorium, dismisses appeals SC upholds Benami Act attachment during IBC moratorium, dismisses appeals Supreme Court of India upheld property attachment under Benami law during IBC moratorium, affirming NCLAT and NCLT rulings and impacting insolvency proceedings for corporate debtors and lenders.
BREAKING – Donald Trump Begins US State Of The Uni…
BREAKING – Donald Trump Begins US State Of The Uni…
BREAKING – Donald Trump Begins US State Of The Uni…
Join Us
Log in / Sign up
Become a Member
Language
Latest news
Live Updates
Markets
Markets Data
Business
Personal Finance
Impact Shorts
Economy
India
World
Upcoming Events
Engage with CNBC-TV18
Healthcare
Politics
Travel
Education & Careers
Sports
Views
Auto
Entertainment
Technology
Startups
Lifestyle
Retail
Real Estate
Minis
Special Coverage
India Business Leader Awards
Branded Content
Discover CNBCTV18
Shows
Anchors
Polls
11:11 Newsletter
Life
Advertise with us
Trending
Stock Market
Q3 Results
IPO
Nifty
Sensex
Trump Tariffs
Gold Price Today
Stocks To Buy
Stocks To Watch
US Market
Watch Live TV
Latest News
Market
Budget
Personal Finance
Impact Shorts
Games
Business
Economy
Travel
Web Stories
Photos
Videos
Sports
Lifestyle
Entertainment
Technology
Polls
Quiz
Minis
Access
NewIPO
NewGames
#MFCorner
#NavigateWithHSBC
#NiveshKaSahiKadam
In Trends
Stock Market
IDFC First Bank Shares
Clean Max Enviro IPO
UPL shares
Stocks To Buy
Stocks To Watch
Trump Tariffs
HomeIndia NewsSC upholds Benami Act attachment during IBC moratorium, dismisses appeals
SC upholds Benami Act attachment during IBC moratorium, dismisses appeals
Supreme Court of India upheld property attachment under Benami law during IBC moratorium, affirming NCLAT and NCLT rulings and impacting insolvency proceedings for corporate debtors and lenders.
ADVERTISEMENT
Profile image
By Timsy Jaipuria
February 24, 2026, 9:00:46 PM IST (Published)
5 Min Read
Impact Shorts
CNBCTV18 on Google
SC upholds Benami Act attachment during IBC moratorium, dismisses appeals
In a ruling that could have far-reaching implications for insolvency proceedings and enforcement under economic offence laws, the Supreme Court of India on Tuesday dismissed appeals challenging the attachment of property under the Benami law during the moratorium period under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).
ADVERTISEMENT
The top court upheld the concurrent findings of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) and the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), effectively ruling that such attachment can stand even when insolvency proceedings are underway and a moratorium is in force.
Latest Access
Aviation losses may narrow by one-third in FY27 but can IndiGo catch up?
The detailed judgment is awaited, but legal experts say the decision reinforces a key principle: enforcement actions determining the nature of property, particularly under economic offence statutes, may not be barred by the IBC moratorium.
The core dispute
The case revolved around whether authorities were justified in attaching an immovable property of a corporate debtor under the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988, while a moratorium under Section 14 of the IBC was in place.
Under the IBC framework, once insolvency proceedings begin, a moratorium is imposed that typically halts recovery actions, legal proceedings, and enforcement measures against the corporate debtor. The idea is to preserve the company’s assets and ensure a fair resolution process for creditors.
Before the NCLAT, the appellant argued that the attachment order passed by the Income Tax Department was invalid because the moratorium should have prevented any such action against the corporate debtor’s property.
However, the appellate tribunal rejected this argument. It held that the transaction in question fell within the ambit of the Benami law and that invoking provisions of the IBC — including those relating to immunity or jurisdiction of the insolvency tribunal — would not help the appellant.
Read More: Supreme Court backs Bank of India in ₹1,500 crore loan default case, clarifies rules on bank ‘fraud’ classification
Importantly, the NCLAT observed that attachment under the Benami law is not a debt-recovery mechanism but a statutory determination about whether a property is held benami, or in someone else’s name.
The Supreme Court has now endorsed this view by dismissing the appeals.
Why the ruling matters
The judgment addresses a recurring legal conflict in India’s insolvency ecosystem: whether enforcement actions under other statutes can continue once a company enters insolvency resolution.
Over the past few years, courts have dealt with similar issues in cases involving laws related to economic offences, including money laundering and undisclosed assets. Authorities have often argued that such proceedings are not meant to recover dues but to determine the legality or ownership of property.
By upholding the attachment, the Supreme Court appears to have strengthened the position that certain statutory actions — especially those tied to alleged wrongdoing — may operate outside the shield of the IBC moratorium.
Suggested For You
MP’s Ruthia family claims British government owes them crores against a ₹35,000 loan for WWI
This could have significant implications for corporate debtors, lenders, and resolution professionals.
Impact on insolvency cases and lenders
For lenders and insolvency professionals, the ruling underscores a potential risk: assets that are attached under special statutes may remain outside the resolution pool even during insolvency proceedings.
If properties are found to be benami and attached by authorities, they may not be available for distribution among creditors during the resolution process. This could affect recovery prospects in large insolvency cases.
At the same time, the judgment also signals that insolvency proceedings cannot be used as a protective cover against investigations or actions related to economic offences.
Amit Maheshwari, Managing Partner at AKM Global, said the decision is significant and aligns with earlier judicial trends.
“This decision is an important one. While one waits for the copy of the judgment to come by, the details available in the public domain suggest that the Supreme Court seems to have upheld the decision of the lower authorities,” Maheshwari said.
He noted that in an earlier matter involving Senthil Papers and Boards Pvt. Ltd., the NCLAT had observed that attachment under the Benami law is not a debt-recovery exercise but a statutory determination regarding the nature of property.
Also Read: Why India’s housing sales are slowing despite rising values
According to Maheshwari, jurisprudence around attachments under laws dealing with economic offences during the moratorium period has evolved along similar lines.
“The IBC should not become an amnesty route for the corporate debtor to discharge the civil liability owed to creditors,” he added.
A growing legal trend
The ruling comes at a time when courts are increasingly being called upon to balance two competing priorities: ensuring effective insolvency resolution while allowing enforcement agencies to act against suspected economic wrongdoing.
Legal experts say the judgment could influence how future cases involving attachments under special statutes, including tax and anti-money laundering laws, are treated during insolvency proceedings.
Once the detailed order is released, stakeholders will closely examine the reasoning of the Supreme Court to understand the boundaries between insolvency protection and enforcement action.
For now, the verdict reinforces a clear message: the IBC moratorium may not automatically shield corporate debtors from statutory actions aimed at determining whether assets were held unlawfully.
Check out the latest updates about the India News, Politics News and Breaking News on CNBC-TV18. Explore more India & World news, Expaliners and Interviews on CNBC TV18. Also, Watch our channels CNBC-TV18, CNBC Awaaz and CNBC Bajar Live on-the-go!
Tags
Insolvency & Bankruptcy CodeNational Company Law Appellate Tribunal
AI data centre boom may lift capital goods orders in India: IIFL names Netweb, ABB among picks – CNBC TV18
Discover
Prefer retail NBFCs over gold lenders; avoid BPOs, mid-tier IT firms on watchlist: Deven Choksey – CNBC TV18
Discover
HDFC Mutual Fund
Explore SIPs to benefit from all market conditions.
Read More
Skip
Indian IT stocks nearing 2008 crash-era valuations: Wedbush’s Moshe Katri – CNBC TV18
Discover
India has leapfrogged other countries in AI adoption, says Adobe’s Shantanu Narayen – CNBC TV18
Discover
4 Simple Ways To Earn Passive Income With Stablecoins
ZebPay
|
Sponsored
India Strengthens Crypto Oversight With Global Data Sharing Framework | ZebPay
ZebPay
|
Sponsored
Ponniammanmedu: Best English Speaking Course for Kids
Train your child to speak like a leader.
Planet Spark
|
Sponsored
Explore new NFO
Invest in Motilal Oswal Multi Factor Passive FoF
Motilal Oswal Mutual Fund
|
Sponsored
15k/Month invested since 2005 is now worth 1.14Cr*
Plan today, Stay future ready!
Axis Max Life
|
Sponsored
Eight IT stocks get price target cuts from CLSA but firm highlights why it remains optimistic
CNBC TV18
People with knee and hip pain should read this!
Neuracare
|
Sponsored
Indians over 65 are switching from hearing aids to this new device.
Recommended by audiologist
Hearing Aids
|
Sponsored
Best Retirement Plans for You | Get 26.8 Cr tax free corpus
Plan today, Stay future ready!
Axis Max Life
|
Sponsored
Ponniammanmedu: Best Public Speaking Course for Children
Exclusively for Ages 4-15
Planet Spark
|
Sponsored
News
Business
Markets
Stocks
Economy
Personal Finance
Sports
India
Education
Politics
Technology
Auto
Startup
Popular Categories
Companies
Stocks
World
Travel
Lifestyle
Education & Careers
Views
Webstories
Photos
Entertainment
Environment
Healthcare
Podcast
Calculators
Pension Calculator
Inflation Calculator
Term Insurance Calculator
SIP Calculator
HRA Calculator
Home Loan Calculator
EMI Calculator
Personal Loan Calculator
Education Loan Calculator
FD Calculator
RD Calculator
PPF Calculator
EPF Calculator
Gratuity Calculator
Trending Now
Stock Market
Q3 Results
IPO
Nifty
Sensex
Trump Tariffs
Gold Price Today
Stocks To Buy
Stocks To Watch
US Market
Live TV
Live TV
CNBC Awaaz LIVE TV
CNBC Bajar LIVE TV
Market
Market Live
Nifty50
Sensex
quick Links
T&C
Contact
Privacy Policy
Advertise with Us
Terms of Use
Disclaimer
Apps
Let’s Connect with CNBCTV 18
Network 18 Group :
Moneycontrol
TopperLearning
Overdrive
News18
Cricketnext
Forbes India
Firstpost
©TV18 Broadcast Limited. All rights reserved.
Open in App
X
Home
Markets
Budget’26
Live TV
