Follow:
- Next story Mhc advt lashminarayanan lecture full video www.sekarreporter.com
- Previous story The Hon’ble Mr. Justice M.M. Sundresh, Judge, Madras High Court has kindly consented to handover the cheques with the respective Presidents/Secretaries of the Chennai Distirct Bar/Advocates Associations in the presence of Hon’ble Mr. Justice N. Kirubakaran, Judge, Madras High Court and office bearers and Members of the Bar Council of Tamil Nadu & Puducherry on Monday the 18th May, 2020 at 1-30 P.M. in the Bar Council Premise
Recent Posts
- csk fan – personality rights order// THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE P.B. BALAJI OA No. 1229 of 2026, A.Nos.4827 & 4828 of 2026 in C.S(COMM DIV) No. 303 of 2026 CNR:{HCMA012661542026} Saravanan Hari
- Periyar Library case THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE G.R.SWAMINATHAN AND THE HON’BLE MRS.JUSTICE M.D.SUMATHI CONT P(MD) No. 3763 of 2026 CNR:{HCMD011622922026} Ramasubbu
- BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT DATED: 16-11-2026 CORAM THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE G.R.SWAMINATHAN AND THE HON’BLE MRS.JUSTICE M.D.SUMATHI CONT P(MD) No. 3763 of 2026 CNR:{HCMD011622922026} Ramasubbu S/o. Late S. Vijayakumar, Door No.8/18C, Sri Sakthi Nagar, Krishnapuram, Tirunelveli District -627 011. ..Petitioner(s) Vs 1. K.Gopal, IAS, The Secretry to Government, Department of Higher Education, Secretariat, Fort St.George, Chennai. 2. R.V.Shajeevana IAS, Director of Public Libraries, Public Libraries Directorate, 737/1, Anna Salai, Chennai -600 002. ..Respondent(s) Prayer : Contempt Petition filed under Section 11 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 to initiate contempt proceedings against Respondents 1 and 2 for their wilful deliberate, and contumacious disobedience of the directions issued in the Judgment dated 19.06.2024 in W.P. (MD) No. 10150 of 2019 and punish the contemnors/respondents in their personal and official capacities with maximum imprisonment and fine. For Petitioner(s): Mr.K.P.S.Palanivel Rajan, for Mr.P.M.Vishnu Varthanan For Respondent(s): Mr.Vijay Narayan, Advocate General, assisted by, Mr.P.V.Balasubramanian, Additional Advocate General, & Mr.B.Saravanan, Additional Advocate General, assisted by, Mr.M.Kannan, Special Government Pleader. Mr.R.John Sathyan, State Public Prosecutor, assisted by, Mr.D.Venkatesh, Additional Public Prosecutor. ORDER (Order of the Court was made by G.R. SWAMINATHAN J.) Heard the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner and the learned Advocate General, Additional Advocate Generals and the learned State Public Prosecutor. 2. This morning we had posed the following queries:- i) Procurement of books has been categorised into two. a) General and b) special. Procurement for Periyar Arivulagam was under the special category. It may be clarified whether the same principles and conditions governing general procurement was applied to special procurement also. ii) How many days were taken to select and procure the books for Kalaignar Library, Madurai and Periyar Arivulagam? iii) How many books were procured for Kalaignar Library, Madurai (January to December, 2025) and Periyar Arivulagam? iv) When procurement was made in two stages under the Transparency Rules, how many books were rejected by expert committee? How many books rejected by the expert committee were procured for Periyar Arivulagam? v) How many books were recommended by the 137-member expert committee? What was the time granted for this process? How many books were procured? vi) It was submitted on the last occasion that Agalvilakku submitted 2300 and odd titles and that 1700 were selected and procured. Who rejected the 600 titles of Agalvilakku and at what stage? What was the reason for such rejection? Copies of the minutes to be made available. If 600 titles of a publisher could be rejected, what made the officials to select and purchase the remaining 1700? vii) How many English books were purchased for Periyar Arivulagam? Whether directly from publishers or from book sellers? What was the budget allotted for English books and Tamil books respectively? Has the entire budget amount has been utilised? viii) Was the work of the librarians who were appointed as Nodal and Coordinating Officials overseen by the Director of Public Libraries and School Education Secretary? Were the files perused by them? Did the Secretary issue any written instruction? ix) How many books were not procured even though they were recommended by the expert committee? What were the reasons?” 3. When the matter was taken up for hearing in the afternoon, the learned Advocate General submitted that he would need some more time to respond. He assured this Court that all the persons involved in the scam will be dealt with. He added that five officials have already been suspended in connection with this scam. 4. The learned State Public Prosecutor submitted that pursuant to the departmental enquiry as well as the direction given by this Court, DVAC, Chennai City have registered FIR in Crime No. 4 of 2026 for various offences under the BNS as well as the Prevention of Corruption Act. Agalvilakku’s Proprietor Mr.Mohan who figures prominently in the scam has been named as one of the accused. 5. The learned Advocate General submitted that if any suggestion comes from this Court as regards streamlining the future procurement processes, that would definitely be considered by the Government. 6. Thiru. Badrinarayanan Seshadri of Kizhakku Padhippagam, who appeared and assisted this Court as a stakeholder, has sent us a note which has been enclosed with this order as Annexure ‘A’. Two other stake holders who do not want themselves to be named have also placed their suggestions. They are enclosed as Annexures ‘B’ and ‘C’. We expect and hope that the Government will go through all the three notes with utmost care and attention and respond on a positive note by the next hearing date. The earlier guidelines have been rendered toothless. It is time to evolve a foolproof procedure. Since the suggestions are fairly comprehensive, it should not take too long to issue a formal G.O so that we do not witness another scam in books procurement. Once such a binding procedure is put in place, we shall close this contempt petition. We would of course issue suitable directions. 7. We take judicial notice of the fact that library cess is levied and collected. We want to know if the cess amount so collected has been duly credited. We also want to know how the said amount has been spent so far. The affidavit to be filed by the authorities shall devote a paragraph to this aspect also. Some impleading applications have been filed. They will be considered on the next hearing date. 8. The Government would do well to undertake a detailed probe and come out with a statement by the next hearing date as to how procurement of books has taken place for the last twenty years and more. It would be in order if a White paper is submitted. The scam has shaken the conscience of the people of Tamil Nadu. Their faith in the system must be restored. 9. We have expressed such sentiments because two icons of Tamil Nadu, namely, Shri.E.V.Ramaswamy(reverentially called as Periyar) and Shri.C.N.Annadurai (Arignar Anna) have impressed upon us the importance of libraries and general reading. Periyar remarked as follows:- “Schools promote literacy and knowledge in a particular field. But the library fosters awareness of general knowledge in all spheres” “gs;spf;$lq;fs; vOj;jwpitAk;> Fwpg;gpl;l Jiwfspy; mwpitAk; tsh;f;fpd;wd. Mdhy;> E}yfq;fNsh midj;Jj; JiwfspYk; nghJ mwpit tsh;f;fpd;wd.” Anna once famously remarked that the library should be accorded a place next to the basic necessities of life, in the following terms:- “tho;f;ifapy; mbg;gilj; NjitfSf;F mLj;j ,lk; Gj;jfr; rhiyf;F jug;glNtz;Lk;.” 10. We are conscious that the Court should not direct the investigation officer to arrest any particular accused. But the case on hand falls under an exceptional category. The bogus publishers have already been identified. Or at least some of them. Unless they are custodially interrogated, one will never know how much money was paid to which public servant. The modus operandi must be brought out. Unlike the earlier scams, the present one rises not only on scale but also the manner in which it has been committed. For the first time, AI and digital processes have been subverted for achieving sinister ends. Of course, these matters fall within the realm of the police. We are sure that by the next hearing date, we will get a better picture. 11. Call this case on 20.11.2026 at 10.30 a.m., as first item. (G.R.S.,J.) (M.D.S.,J.) 16-11-2026 PMU Encl: Annexures A, B and C. 1. K.Gopal, IAS The Secretry to Government Department of Higher Education Secretariat Fort St.George Chennai 2. R.V.Shajeevana IAS Director of Public Libraries Public Libraries Directorate 737/1, Anna Salai Chennai -600 002 Annexure – A Badrinarayanan Seshadri 3A, Sri Gurukrupa Apartments 7/9, CP Ramaswamy Street Abhiramapuram, Chennai 600018 To HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE G.R. SWAMINATHAN AND HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.D. SUMATHI Madras High Court, Madurai Bench Date: 13/11/2026 Sub: Concerns about procurement of books to public libraries in Tamil Nadu and how the process can be improved Respected Justices, 1. I am Badrinarayanan Seshadri, publisher of Kizhakku Pathippagam, one of the leading Tamil publishers. I have been publishing books in Tamil since 2004. To this day, we have published more than 2500 Tamil titles, most of them nonfiction, covering biographies, political histories, current a^airs, business, finance, economics, self-help, religion, healthcare, history, science and literature. We have also published some fiction, both short stories and novels. 2. I have a B.Tech from IIT Madras and a Ph.D from Cornell University (USA) in the field of Mechanical Engineering. I am a serial entrepreneur, and have run or am running multiple, successful businesses such as Cricinfo (1996-2005), Kizhakku Pathippagam (2004-), Synprosoft (2014-), Argee Sta^ing Services (2018-2022), Ascendency Interlinks (2023-), and Syncretic Media (2025-), in the space of cricket information, Tamil book publishing, software services on Zoho platform, IT sta^ing, BNI franchise and YouTube video content generation. 3. Under Kizhakku Pathippagam, I have not only published books, but also edited many of the titles, written a few books and translated some from English to Tamil. I have also devised strategies for selling these books across Tamil Nadu in every nook and corner including in restaurants, textile shops, supermarkets, grocery stores and even the petty shops and tea shops across small towns and villages. I have been the first to deploy all kinds of new technologies, namely audio books, Kindle e-books, print-on-demand etc. 4. We have always strived to bring the best books to Tamil and have bought translation rights to more than 200 English titles and published their Tamil translations. We have routinely commissioned Tamil books from reputed authors, in a variety of topics and we are proud of the easy readability we have brought into our books, as well as the attractive packaging, cover design, catchy titles, layout clarity etc. 5. We are an ethical publisher. We have never offered bribe in all these 22 years to anyone for the procurement of our books by the Dept of Public Libraries. We have always applied for all our titles and have fulfilled whatever orders we have received, however small they were, without ever complaining. 6. I have been observing the corruption and irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu for the last 22 years. Over this period, I have consistently voiced my concerns through my blogs, newspaper articles, public discussions and videos. The recent controversy involving the procurement of allegedly fraudulent, AIgenerated and falsely attributed books published by Agal Vilakku and other publishers in large numbers for public libraries across Tamil Nadu has deeply disturbed me. It has once again demonstrated how public money can be diverted towards books of questionable authenticity and value, while genuine authors and publishers struggle to have their books acquired by public libraries. 7. To address the systemic flaws that have enabled such irregularities, I would like to offer the following suggestions. Many of these principles have already been articulated in the excellent judgment of the Hon’ble Madras High Court dated 19 June 2024 in W.P.(MD) No. 10150 of 2019 — S. Krishnan vs. The Secretary to Government, Department of Higher Education. That judgment directed the Government to implement its Transparent Book Procurement Policy, publish shortlisted books, invite public objections for one month, preserve those objections, and investigate past procurement irregularities. The subsequent orders dated 10 and 11 November 2026 in Contempt Petition (MD) No. 3763 of 2026 — Ramasubbu vs. K. Gopal, IAS, have further exposed the failure to implement these directions in letter and spirit. Particularly relevant is the observation in the order dated 11 November 2026 that the Directorate should consider publishing a comprehensive record of books procured over the preceding two decades, including titles, quantities and payments. The Court also recorded the importance of disclosing the dates on which publishers submitted their bills and the dates on which payments were settled. Although the Court clarified that this was not yet a formal direction, it is an important recommendation deserving immediate attention. I am therefore restating some of the Court’s recommendations, while adding further suggestions to establish a fair, transparent, efficient and accountable procurement system. I. Transparency and Public Accountability A. Complete transparency in the selection process The entire book selection process, beginning with the invitation for publishers to submit catalogues and books, through evaluation by subject experts, shortlisting, determination of quantities and final approval, must be completely transparent. The names of the selection committee members, the criteria adopted for evaluating books, the individual and consolidated evaluation scores, and the reasons for selecting or rejecting books should be available for public scrutiny. Where an official or committee changes the recommendation of an expert, that change must be documented with the reasons and the authority responsible. The procedures prescribed in the 2024 S. Krishnan judgment should be fully implemented. Merely establishing an online procurement portal cannot be considered sufficient compliance unless the actual decisions made through that system are transparent. B. Public right to review and criticise book selections As directed in the 2024 judgment, the complete list of shortlisted books, including their titles, authors, publishers, cover images, prices and proposed quantities, must be made available for public examination. The public, including readers, authors, publishers, librarians and subject experts, should be allowed at least one month to submit comments, criticisms and objections. All such comments must remain publicly accessible and should never be deleted merely because they are critical of the Directorate or its decisions. Before finalising procurement, the authorities should publish their responses to substantive objections, explaining why the relevant books have been retained, removed or otherwise reconsidered. This will ensure that public consultation is meaningful rather than a procedural formality. C. Public disclosure of purchase orders, supplies and payments The Directorate should maintain a publicly accessible database containing complete information about every book procured using public funds. For every title, the database should disclose: • ISBN, book title, author, publisher, edition and original publication year. • Number of copies ordered and the libraries for which they are intended. • Printed price, negotiated price, discount and total purchase value. • Date of issue of the purchase order. • Date of delivery and acceptance of the books. • Date of submission of the publisher’s or supplier’s invoice. • Date of approval and actual release of payment. The proposed purchase orders should be published before final approval, and the final purchase orders, delivery records and payments should be disclosed as the procurement progresses. The information should be available in searchable and downloadable formats, including CSV or Excel, rather than only as scanned documents. Historical disclosure: The Directorate should also publish a consolidated database of book procurement for the preceding 20 years, to the extent that records are available, with missing records clearly identified. This will make it possible to identify unusual procurement patterns, excessive concentration of orders among particular publishers, repeated purchases of the same books and preferential payment practices. In particular, allegations have been made that certain publishers, including Agal Vilakku, received preferential treatment both in the quantity of books ordered and the speed with which their payments were processed. Publication of the underlying records will help establish the facts objectively. Such disclosure, by itself, can become one of the strongest safeguards against favouritism and corruption. D. Preservation of a complete digital audit trail Every action performed through the book procurement portal must be preserved in a secure, tamper-evident digital audit trail. This should include the original submissions made by publishers, expert evaluations, scores, recommendations, changes made by officials, approvals, purchase orders and payment authorisations. No recommendation or score should be altered without preserving the earlier version, the identity of the person making the change, the date and time, and the reason for the modification. Periodic independent technical audits should verify that the books finally ordered are the same books that were evaluated, shortlisted and approved through the prescribed process. This would help prevent manipulation of procurement decisions after the expert evaluation stage. II. Institutional Accountability and Prevention of Corruption E. Disclosure of publisher ownership and conflicts of interest Every publisher and distributor participating in library procurement should disclose the identity of its legal owners, beneficial owners, partners, directors and related publishing entities. Where multiple publishing houses operate under different names but have common ownership or control, such relationships should be made public. This is necessary to identify instances where the same individuals may be using multiple imprints to secure a disproportionate share of government procurement. Members of selection committees, expert panels and procurement authorities should also disclose material financial, professional or familial relationships with publishers, authors or distributors whose books they evaluate. Persons having such conflicts of interest must recuse themselves from the relevant decisions. Deliberate concealment of material relationships should attract appropriate disqualification and disciplinary consequences. F. Independent annual audit of procurement There should be an annual independent audit of the entire book procurement process. This audit should examine the selection of titles, compliance with evaluation procedures, quantities purchased, pricing, discounts, delivery records, payments and possible conflicts of interest. Random physical verification should be undertaken at public libraries to establish whether the books recorded as delivered were actually received and are available for borrowing. The audit report and the Government’s action-taken report should be made public every year. In view of the recent controversy, a special forensic audit of procurement over the preceding five years should also be considered. Its objective should be to identify systemic irregularities, quantify financial losses where established, and determine responsibility for fraudulent transactions. G. Public grievance redressal mechanism A permanent, independent grievance redressal mechanism should be established for authors, publishers, librarians, readers and members of the public. Complaints may concern unfair exclusion of books, questionable selection, inflated prices, plagiarism, fabricated authorship, unauthorised translations, copyright violations, procurement manipulation or corruption. Every complaint should be acknowledged within seven days and ordinarily disposed of through a reasoned decision within 30 days, with an extension permitted for complex cases. An appellate mechanism should be available, particularly where the complaint concerns officials of the Directorate itself. Reasonable safeguards should be provided to protect complainants and whistleblowers against retaliation, while preventing misuse through knowingly false complaints. III. Decentralisation and Better Use of Library Funds H. Local versus centralised book procurement Keralam offers an example of a more decentralised approach in which local library institutions exercise considerable discretion over their collections. Local librarians are often better positioned to understand the interests, reading habits, language preferences and educational needs of their communities than officials making purchase decisions centrally. Tamil Nadu may consider adopting a hybrid procurement model under which 50% of the available procurement funds are allocated to individual libraries for local selection and 50% are retained for centralised procurement. This could initially be implemented as a pilot programme across selected districts and subsequently expanded after evaluating its effectiveness. Clear guidelines should provide for the participation of local librarians, library users, local government representatives and community members in the selection process. Local libraries should be permitted to acquire books outside the centrally approved shortlist, subject to transparent procedures, reasonable price controls and appropriate audit requirements. Centralised procurement should continue to serve purposes such as statewide acquisitions, significant reference collections, specialised works and titles that benefit from bulk purchasing. Decentralisation must not merely transfer the opportunity for corruption from the State level to the local level. The same transparency and accountability standards should apply to both systems. I. Encouraging donations of books to libraries The present process of donating books to public libraries is unnecessarily difficult and discourages individuals and institutions who wish to contribute to public education and I have personally experienced this problem. A donor was willing to purchase 2,000 copies of a few important books published by Kizhakku Pathippagam and donate them to public libraries in Tamil Nadu. Despite approaching the library authorities, we could not obtain a meaningful response. Consequently, a valuable opportunity was lost. The Directorate of Public Libraries should establish a formal policy for accepting donations of books, supported by a permanent committee empowered to evaluate such offers. Every proposal should receive a written acceptance or rejection within 30 days, with reasons. The policy should allow the evaluation of a representative set of donated titles rather than imposing unnecessary administrative requirements on donors. Donation procedures must also ensure that libraries are not compelled to accept unsuitable or unwanted books, and that donor interests do not compromise collection quality. A transparent donation policy would encourage philanthropists, publishers, institutions, foundations and individuals to contribute meaningfully to the public library system. J. Reader preferences, actual usage and procurement planning Book procurement should ultimately be assessed by how effectively public libraries serve their readers, not merely by the number of titles purchased or the amount of money spent. The Directorate should collect and periodically publish aggregate information regarding circulation, reader requests, frequently borrowed titles, underused books and unmet demand. Library users should have a simple mechanism to recommend books for acquisition. These data should inform future purchasing decisions, particularly at the local level. However, circulation statistics should not become the sole criterion for selection. Important works of history, philosophy, literature, science and cultural heritage may deserve a place in public libraries even when their immediate readership is limited. The privacy of individual borrowers must also be protected. Public reporting should be based on aggregate usage data, not identifiable borrowing histories. IV. More Efficient and Economical Procurement Models K. Nationalised works, public-domain books and duplicate purchases Tamil Nadu has a distinguished tradition of nationalising literary works, making important books more widely accessible to the public. However, the procurement of nationalised and public-domain works has also created opportunities for wasteful expenditure and fraudulent repackaging. The same works are frequently published by different publishers, sometimes with new covers, modified titles or misleading attribution, and repeatedly procured for libraries. A familiar example is Kalki’s Ponniyin Selvan, which is available in numerous editions from different publishers. Such purchases can crowd out other valuable books and deprive contemporary writers and publishers of opportunities to reach library readers. For standard nationalised works, the Government should consider preparing or approving authoritative editions and inviting competitive tenders for printing, binding and delivery. This would enable the Government to procure large numbers of copies at substantially lower costs, while maintaining appropriate standards of textual accuracy, printing and binding. At the same time, genuine new translations, critical editions, annotated versions, scholarly introductions and materially improved editions should continue to be eligible for procurement. A central bibliographic database should help identify substantial duplication, including works republished under different titles, names or ISBNs. The objective should be to prevent wasteful repetition and misrepresentation, not to discourage legitimate publishing activity. L. Procurement of educational, academic and reference books from national and international publishers For educational, academic, scientific and reference books published by national and international publishers, the Directorate should first identify the required titles and editions through an appropriate expert selection process. Once the titles and quantities are finalised, procurement should be undertaken through competitive tendering among authorised booksellers and distributors. These suppliers would be able to aggregate orders, negotiate discounts with publishers and offer competitive prices for procurement and delivery. The tender process should consider the final delivered price, including applicable taxes, shipping and handling charges, and should verify that the supplier is authorised to provide the relevant editions. This would be more efficient and transparent than relying on individual discretionary purchase arrangements. Where exclusive distribution rights or other legitimate constraints prevent competition, the reasons for adopting an alternative procurement method should be documented and disclosed. M. Procurement and lending of e-books A growing number of Tamil publishers have begun releasing books in digital formats. The Government should evolve a comprehensive policy for acquiring, licensing and lending Tamil e-books through the public library network. Residents of Tamil Nadu should be able to register with the public library system and borrow eligible e-books through an online platform, broadly comparable in user experience to commercial digital reading services such as Kindle Unlimited or Everand. A dedicated annual fund should be established for procuring or licensing digital books. Publishers may be compensated through a combination of agreed licensing fees and verified usage-based payments, taking into account actual borrowing and reading activity. Appropriate safeguards should prevent manipulation of download counts, artificial reading activity and other forms of fraudulent claims. The policy must address copyright, digital lending rights, accessibility, data privacy, reasonable lending limits and fair compensation to authors and publishers. In addition to widening access, a well-designed e-book lending system could significantly benefit readers in rural areas and smaller towns who may not have ready access to large physical collections. V. Publishing Integrity and Enforcement N. Undertakings by publishers and authors regarding authenticity, copyright and AI-generated content Every publisher supplying books to public libraries must provide a legally enforceable undertaking concerning the authenticity, authorship and copyright status of the books submitted. The publisher must certify that: 1. Every named author is a real and identifiable person who has authorised publication of the work. 2. The publisher possesses the necessary rights to publish and supply the book. 3. The work does not contain plagiarised material, fabricated authorship, deliberately falsified content or unauthorised reproduction of copyrighted works. 4. In the case of translations, the necessary translation rights have been obtained from the original copyright holder wherever such permission is legally required. 5. The work has been subjected to appropriate editorial and factual scrutiny, and the publisher accepts responsibility for the authenticity of the submitted publication. 6. Any substantial use of generative AI in producing the substantive content of the book has been disclosed, distinguishing such use from ordinary editorial assistance, proofreading, indexing or other supporting functions. Publishers should, in turn, obtain appropriate declarations from the respective authors, translators and editors. The intention is not to prohibit legitimate technological assistance in publishing, but to prevent the supply of fraudulent, fabricated, plagiarised or falsely attributed books in the guise of genuine literary or scholarly publications. Consequences of violation If a book is found, after appropriate verification and due process, to violate these undertakings, the publisher should be required to withdraw all affected copies supplied to public libraries at its own expense and refund the amounts received from the Government. Additional penalties may be imposed according to the nature and seriousness of the violation. Deliberate or repeated serious fraud should attract long-term or permanent debarment from future government procurement, following notice and an opportunity to respond. Where criminal offences are disclosed, appropriate prosecution should follow. These safeguards should apply equally to books in Tamil, English and other languages. O. Time-bound implementation and continuing public oversight One of the most disturbing aspects of the current controversy is that many of the necessary safeguards were already prescribed in the 2024 High Court judgment. The subsequent events indicate that the mere existence of a policy, government order or online portal is insufficient. The Government should therefore publish a time-bound implementation roadmap for all the reforms proposed above. The roadmap should specify the responsibility of the relevant department or official, the implementation deadline, and measurable criteria for determining compliance. Quarterly public reports should disclose the progress of reforms, procurement expenditure, audit findings, complaints received and resolved, and corrective measures undertaken. An annual review involving independent experts, authors, publishers, librarians and representatives of library users should examine whether the procurement system is genuinely serving the public interest. The implementation reports should be permanently accessible on the Directorate’s website. The ultimate purpose of public library procurement is not to provide business opportunities to publishers or distributors, but to make the best possible books available to the people of Tamil Nadu through the efficient and fair use of public funds. A transparent procurement system should simultaneously protect public money, encourage genuine authors and publishers, preserve our literary and intellectual heritage, and respond to the needs of readers. Tamil Nadu has a rich publishing tradition and an extensive public library network. It should be possible for the State to establish a model procurement system that other States in India would wish to emulate. The recent controversy should therefore be treated not merely as an isolated incident requiring investigation and punishment, but as an opportunity to undertake lasting structural reform. I request the Government to initiate a time-bound consultation with publishers, authors, librarians, readers and independent experts, and implement the necessary reforms with clear provisions for transparency, accountability and independent oversight. Above all, the Government must ensure that the rules and procedures prescribed for transparent procurement are implemented in practice, and that compliance can be independently verified by the public. Annexure – B Strengthening Book Procurement for Public Libraries in Tamil Nadu Supplementary safeguards under the Transparent Book Procurement Policy 2024 and a proposal for a High Level Expert Committee Note for Government consideration Part I Existing policy and the need for supplementary safeguards 1. Existing policy framework The Government of Tamil Nadu has established a comprehensive framework for transparent procurement of books for public libraries through the Transparent Book Procurement Policy, 2024, issued in G.O.(Ms) No.69, School Education Department, dated 07.03.2024. The policy provides for online applications, bibliographic particulars and review copies, point-based evaluation by subject experts, participation of librarians and readers, quality verification, a Book Price Index, online price negotiation, and procedures for ordering, supply and payment. It also addresses personal bias and unfair practices, including alteration of titles or authors’ names, unauthorised reproduction, manipulation of publication particulars, artificial inflation of page counts and supply of inferior books. 2. Compliance with existing requirements The first requirement is consistent implementation of the existing policy in its entirety. Every prescribed safeguard shall be supported by a verifiable administrative process, a designated responsible authority, supporting records and supervisory checks. The High Court’s judgment dated 19.06.2024 in W.P.(MD) No.10150 of 2019 additionally requires procurement in consonance with the policy, a functional public portal, publication of shortlisted books with relevant particulars and covers, and a month’s opportunity for public remarks and objections before finalisation. These are existing compliance obligations and shall be incorporated into the procurement calendar. 3. Need for further strengthening Concerns relating to fabricated publications, fictitious authorship, misuse of bibliographic identifiers, undisclosed machine-generated content and manipulation of digital selection records warrant a focused review. The exercise shall distinguish failures in implementation, procedural gaps requiring clarification, and emerging risks requiring policy amendments. The existing framework may accordingly be preserved and strengthened through targeted supplementary safeguards. Part II Additional safeguards proposed for consideration 4. Authenticity of content and disclosure of AI use Every application may carry a title-specific declaration from the publisher, supported by the author or authorised rights holder wherever reasonably obtainable, confirming the authenticity of authorship, lawful entitlement to publish and supply, and absence of undisclosed reproduction or substantial recycling of other works. The declaration shall disclose whether generative artificial intelligence was used to produce substantive text, translations, illustrations or other material content, and the nature and extent of that use. The policy may distinguish assistance in spelling, formatting or language editing from substantive machine generation presented misleadingly as original human authorship. The declaration should establish responsibility for the work rather than depend upon an unverifiable blanket certification that no AI tool was used at any stage. 5. Technical screening and expert verification A documented screening procedure may identify duplicated text, fabricated references, repetitive or incoherent material, false attribution and substantially identical content submitted under different titles. Automated plagiarism and AI-detection tools may assist in identifying titles requiring closer examination; a software score shall not, by itself, constitute proof of fabrication or a sufficient ground for rejection or penal action. Flagged titles may be referred to an independent content-verification panel for a reasoned assessment. Copying, scanning and processing of review material shall be subject to appropriate copyright permissions and confidentiality safeguards. 6. ISBN and bibliographic verification The requirement that a book carry an ISBN may be supplemented by verification, through the competent ISBN agency or other authoritative records, of its association with the relevant publisher, title, edition and format, to the extent records are available. A valid ISBN shall not be treated as certification of originality, factual accuracy, literary merit or freedom from AI-generated content. Reused, inconsistent or apparently fabricated identifiers shall be clarified before selection. 7. Verification of publishers, authors and connected entities Proportionate documentary requirements may establish the legal identity, business address, ownership and supply authorisation of applicants. Publishers may disclose sister concerns, related imprints and entities under common ownership or control, enabling detection of attempts to circumvent procurement limits or debarment orders. Independent authorship confirmation may be sought where impersonation or false attribution is suspected. Genuine pen names and confidential particulars shall receive appropriate protection. Credible new and small publishers shall be permitted to participate; absence of a large catalogue or long trading history shall not, by itself, establish lack of genuineness. 8. Evidence of publication and availability Independent catalogues, publisher records, bookseller listings, library holdings and reviews may corroborate a title’s existence and publication history. Absence from commercial platforms may warrant verification but shall not automatically disqualify a genuine new publication, specialist work, small-press edition or work intended for a limited readership. 9. Adequate review time and recorded assessment Reasonable review periods, manageable allocations of titles and a standard assessment format may be prescribed. Each title shall have a traceable record of assigned reviewers, completed assessment, scores and decision. Titles awaiting substantive evaluation shall be carried forward rather than cleared merely to meet expenditure or inauguration deadlines. Interest declarations and recusal shall cover financial, professional and publishing relationships capable of affecting impartial assessment. 10. Integrity of the digital selection process The portal may provide separate permissions for recommendation, evaluation, selection, approval and payment; authenticated approval and locking of lists at each stage; tamper-evident logs of additions, deletions and alterations; and reconciliation between expert recommendations, approved titles, orders, deliveries and payments. No title shall enter the final list without prescribed scrutiny. Subsequent additions shall undergo the same applicable process, with their origin and approval recorded. 11. Public scrutiny and disposal of objections The judicial requirement of public display may be operationalised through procedures for publication, acknowledgement, independent examination, reasoned disposal and retention of objections. Published particulars may include the title, author, publisher, ISBN, edition, cover, proposed quantity and procurement price. Objections shall be decided before finalisation. Public disclosure shall include safeguards against exposure of personal information, unlawful material and unsupported personal allegations. 12. Price scrutiny and enhanced approval The Book Price Index and online negotiation requirements may be supplemented by scrutiny of the net price payable against comparable editions, production specifications and independently verifiable market prices. High-value titles, unusually large orders, exceptional prices and substantial concentration within a connected publisher group may require independent appraisal and higher approval. Thresholds, approving authorities and permissible exceptions shall be prescribed in advance. Exceptions shall carry recorded reasons, particularly for specialist reference works, imported publications and accessible formats. 13. Inspection, payment and remedies after supply Inspection may extend beyond paper, printing and binding to sample verification that supplied content corresponds to the reviewed and approved edition. Supply conditions may provide for replacement, rejection, withholding of the disputed portion of payment and recovery of amounts paid for established misrepresentation or non-conforming supply, subject to applicable law and contractual terms. Recovery through any statutory mechanism shall first be examined for legal authority. Debarment shall follow notice, opportunity to respond and a reasoned order, with its scope and duration proportionate to established misconduct. Criminal referral may be made where verified facts disclose a suspected offence; it shall not follow automatically from an adverse software flag. 14. Initial collections for new and special libraries For newly established or special libraries involving large initial collections, a dedicated Standard Operating Procedure may incorporate the applicable safeguards of the 2024 policy and judicial directions. It may recognise expert-led collection building across subjects while requiring recorded evaluation, price scrutiny, public disclosure and traceability of every approved title. 15. Demand aggregation and continuing oversight Minimum aggregate order quantities may be examined against actual demand, delivery costs and collection diversity. Any threshold shall accommodate specialist, minority-language, local-history and accessible-format publications. Periodic procurement audits, sample content audits, supplier-concentration analysis and publication of title-wise expenditure and payment particulars may be introduced to identify recurring weaknesses. Part III Proposed High Level Expert Committee 16. Constitution and composition Government may consider a compact High Level Expert Committee to review the existing policy, its implementation and the accompanying reform suggestions. An indicative composition is set out below. Chairperson: An eminent serving or retired civil servant with substantial administrative experience and recognised engagement with literature, education or public institutions. Government may consider a person such as Thiru V. Irai Anbu, IAS (Retd.), or Thiru T. Udhayachandran, IAS, subject to consent, availability and applicable administrative requirements. Literary member: An eminent writer of recognised standing, such as Professor Perumal Murugan, subject to consent and disclosure of relevant interests. Publishing member: A representative of a reputed publishing institution with substantial editorial and production experience, selected through objective criteria. Library member: A senior library professional experienced in collection development, cataloguing and public-library administration. Technical member: An independent expert in digital audit, information security or content verification. The Directorate may provide secretarial assistance. Finance, Law and other specialists may be invited for specific matters without enlarging permanent membership. 17. Terms of reference (i) Undertake a clause-wise review of the 2024 policy, relevant Government Orders,operational guidelines and applicable judicial directions. (ii) Distinguish implementation deficiencies from gaps in policy design. (iii) Examine the accompanying suggestions and identify measures already prescribed,measures requiring clarification and measures requiring amendment. (iv) Recommend safeguards against fabricated content, false authorship, ISBN misuse,plagiarism, undisclosed substantive AI generation and manipulation of digital records. (v) Define practical responsibilities for publishers, reviewers, librarians, approvingauthorities and payment officers. (vi) Recommend a separate SOP for large initial procurements for new libraries. (vii) Review exceptional procurement routes, high-value approvals, supplier concentrationand conflict-of-interest controls. (viii) Submit draft amendments, standard declarations, inspection formats and animplementation plan specifying authorities and timelines. 18. Independence and scope Members shall disclose relevant interests and abstain from matters affecting their publications, publishing institutions, financial interests or transactions in which they previously participated. The mandate shall concern systemic reform. It shall not substitute for, interfere with or prejudge judicial, vigilance, disciplinary or criminal proceedings. Individual culpability shall remain for determination by the competent authorities. 19. Time frame and deliverables The Committee may submit interim recommendations within thirty days and its final report within ninety days of constitution. A comparative statement may set out each existing provision, identified deficiency, proposed amendment or instruction, implementing authority and means of verifying compliance. Government may thereafter issue necessary amendments and instructions with appropriate legal and financial vetting. 20. Proposal for Government consideration Government may constitute the above High Level Expert Committee to examine the Transparent Book Procurement Policy, 2024, together with the accompanying reform suggestions, and recommend supplementary measures necessary to secure its effective implementation in letter and spirit. The review shall aim to apply public funds to genuine and useful publications through a transparent, accountable and verifiable process, while supporting literary diversity and fair participation by credible publishers. Documents referred to 1. Transparent Book Procurement Policy 2024, supplied policy document; G.O.(Ms) No.69, School EducationDepartment, dated 07.03.2024. 2. Reform of Book Procurement for Public Libraries in Tamil Nadu – A Note of Suggestions, supplied draft. 3. S. Krishnan v. The Secretary to Government, W.P.(MD) No.10150 of 2019, judgment dated 19.06.2024, particularlyparagraph 12. Annexure – C Reform of Book Procurement for Public Libraries in Tamil Nadu: A 1. Purpose of this note 1.1 This note sets out suggestions for reforming the procurement of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu. It takes into account two decisions of the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court. The first is the judgment dated 19.06.2024 in W.P.(MD) No.10150 of 2019 (referred to below as “the 2024 judgment”). The second is the order dated 11.11.2026 in Cont.P.(MD) No.3763 of 2026, which arises out of it (referred to below as “the contempt order”). 1.2 Two different kinds of procurement are involved, so the suggestions are in two parts: (a) Part I: The one-time procurement of a large collection, of one lakh books or more, for newly established special libraries. This is at present done through the committees constituted under G.O.(Ms) No.250, School Education Department, dated 05.11.2025. (b) Part II: The continuous procurement of additions for the existing public libraries. This is governed by the Transparent Book Procurement Policy, 2024, issued in G.O.(Ms) No.69, School Education Department, dated 07.03.2024 (referred to below as “the Transparent Book Procurement Policy”). 1.3 In the 2024 judgment, the High Court observed that “time has come to put in place proper mechanism for such procurement”. It directed that procurement be in line with G.O.(Ms) No.69 and that a dedicated website be maintained. It also directed that every shortlist be published, with the book cover, for a month of remarks and objections before the procurement is finalised. In the contempt order, the Court has recorded that “bound stationery passing for books” has been purchased for various public libraries. 1.4 The suggestions, in brief, are as follows. (a) For special libraries: a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for one-time collection building. It would bring in the good practices of the Transparent Book Procurement Policy together with the transparency directions of the Court, and would be issued along with the Government Order sanctioning each new library. (b) For existing libraries: amendments to the Transparent Book Procurement Policy so that it deals with machine-generated content (including an immediate red flag by reviewers), the qualification of publishers and authors, adequate time for review, a minimum order quantity for each title, and the publication of the shortlist for claims and objections. (c) Common to both: a declaration by the publisher and screening for AI-generated content; a check that each book is actually sold in the open market; verification of the publisher and the author; a mandatory minimum time for review; expert scoring recorded title by title; a price ceiling based on the Book Price Index; a limit on the share of any one publisher; publication of the shortlist for thirty days; a content check before payment and a clause for recovery afterwards. 2. New libraries and existing libraries: why two procedures 2.1 Adding books to a library that already exists is different from stocking a new library from an empty building. The first is a small, regular addition to a collection that is already balanced. The second is the planning and purchase of an entire collection, across every subject, in a single round. The two differ in scale, in who chooses the books, and in where the titles come from. That is why two separate procedures have come into use. Existing libraries New special libraries Libraries covered More than 4,500 district central, branch, village and part-time libraries Periyar Arivulagam (Coimbatore), Kamarajar Arivulagam (Tiruchirappalli), Bharathidasan Arivulagam (Salem), Anjalai Ammal Arivulagam (Cuddalore), Quaid-e-Millath Arivulagam (Tirunelveli), and new district central libraries Nature of purchase Continuous additions and replacements, every quarter One-time purchase of a complete collection, one lakh titles or more Source of funds Library cess, of which up to 25% is used for reading material (Transparent Book Procurement Policy, paras 11 and 15) One-time grant. G.O.(Ms) No.250 provides ₹136 crore in all for books and e-books How titles come in Publishers apply online, book by book, and each book is evaluated and scored Subject experts identify the best titles from syllabi, reference lists, award lists and the catalogues of Indian and foreign publishers Who decides for each library Readers’ circle and librarian, choosing from an approved list (Transparent Book Procurement Policy, para 16) Committees decide centrally for the whole collection Existing libraries New special libraries Range Mainly Tamil; general reading and competitive-examination books Tamil and English, academic and research titles, children’s books, Braille and audio books, e-books and e-journals 2.2 Why the Transparent Book Procurement Policy alone is not enough for a new library: The Transparent Book Procurement Policy depends on publishers applying, title by title. A researchgrade collection of a lakh titles cannot be built that way. Many of the books it must hold are never offered by their publishers: international academic titles, reference works, award winners and government or research publications. Someone has to go looking for them, subject by subject, and that is work only subject experts can do. This is why G.O.(Ms) No.250 created a 137-member Book Recommendation Committee and a 13-member Book Selection Committee. 2.3 Why the committees still need the safeguards of the Transparent Book Procurement Policy: A large one-time purchase is more open to abuse than routine additions. The volume is large, the time is usually short, and a single order can be worth lakhs to one supplier. The safeguards developed in the Transparent Book Procurement Policy therefore matter even more here: scoring, a price ceiling, online negotiation and display of the list. 2.4 Suggested approach: The Transparent Book Procurement Policy is designed for continuous procurement, and G.O.(Ms) No.250 for a one-time purchase. Merging the two into a single framework is therefore not advisable. It is suggested instead that a Standard Operating Procedure for one-time collection building be framed. It would carry over all the good practices of the Transparent Book Procurement Policy, with the changes needed for bulk selection, and include the transparency directions of the Court. The SOP would be issued along with the scheme Government Order for each new library, so that the committees have a fixed procedure to follow from the first day. Its contents are set out in Part I. Part I: Special libraries (one-time procurement of a large collection) 3. The present four-committee process 3.1 G.O.(Ms) No.250 sanctions ₹50 crore each for Coimbatore and Tiruchirappalli, ₹10 crore each for Salem, Cuddalore and Tirunelveli, and ₹1 crore each for six new district central libraries, to buy books and e-books. It constitutes four committees, which work one after another. The Director of Public Libraries coordinates all four. (a) Book Recommendation Committee: with 137 members, about three for each subject. It is made up of professors, writers and specialists in more than fifty subjects. Its task is to recommend the best books in each field. This is the only stage at which a subject expert is meant to look at the book itself. (b) Book Selection Committee: with 13 members. It evaluates the recommended titles and finalises a priority list in five streams: Tamil, English, academic, children’s, and books for the (c) Book Procurement Price Negotiation Committee: with 5 members, all officials of the Directorate and the Finance Department. It negotiates directly with publishers and sellers for the highest discount. (d) High Level Committee: with 5 members. It is chaired by the Principal Secretary to Government, School Education Department, and the Director of Public Libraries is its MemberSecretary. It approves the titles, the number of copies and the prices. 3.2 Annexure I to the G.O. lists the sources from which titles may be drawn. These include online bookstores and review sites, reviews in the media, the reading lists of national universities, catalogues sent by publishers and sellers, bestseller lists and literary awards. 3.3 As a design, the sequence of experts first, then selection, then price, then approval is sound. The weakness is that the G.O. constitutes the committees but lays down no procedure for them. It does not say what each committee must check, in what order, on what record, within what time, or what follows if a stage is skipped. The loopholes discussed below follow from this. 4. Loopholes in special-library procurement and suggested remedies 4.0 The facts recorded in the contempt order show how far the existing safeguards failed. One supplier is said to have offered 2,335 titles, of which 1,700 were selected, and it was paid about ₹17 lakh. An established publisher with hundreds of titles received an order for about ₹23,000. The Court remarked that when not even one book of that supplier is seen in the market, it is difficult to understand how no one’s suspicion was aroused. Whether the experts approved these books, or the books were inserted into the lists at the digital stage without the experts’ knowledge, is under investigation. In either case, the procedure did not prevent it. The loopholes are discussed below, each followed by the remedy suggested for it. 4.1 No check on whether the content is genuine G.O.(Ms) No.250 does not ask whether a book was actually written by a person, whether it reads coherently, or whether its facts are correct. Software can now produce book-length text in a matter of minutes, under any number of titles and author names. A book judged by its title, its cover and a few pages can pass through a committee unnoticed. Full digital texts cannot be demanded as a remedy. Publishers, particularly reputed Tamil, English and foreign publishing houses, will not part with them, for reasons of copyright. A layered check is suggested instead, built on what is practicable: (a) Declaration: For every title, the publisher should declare whether AI software was used in writing, translating or editing it, and to what extent. A false declaration should be treated as an unfair practice, leading to debarment and criminal action. (b) Automated screening of the review copy: The Directorate may scan a fixed number of pages, chosen at random from different parts of the printed review copy, solely for screening and under an undertaking of confidentiality. Where the publisher already offers a digital preview, that may be used. The pages would be compared with all other submissions, to catch the same text recycled under different titles and author names, and with the digitised nationalised works held by Government. They would also be checked with AI-detection tools. A flag only marks the title for closer verification. It is not by itself a ground for rejection, since no tool is fully reliable, particularly for Tamil. (c) Market-existence test: It should be verified whether the book is actually sold in bookshops or online, when it was first published, and whether it has been reviewed or catalogued anywhere. A book printed only for a Government order is a warning sign. (d) Verification of flagged titles: Subject experts are eminent persons serving in an honorary capacity, and they cannot be required to read every book in full. A separate Content Verification Panel may therefore be engaged, made up of retired teachers, research scholars and librarians and paid per title. It would read the flagged titles and report before they go to the experts for scoring. (e) Check on delivery: Librarians should compare the delivered copy with the review copy, and the Verification Panel should examine a random sample of titles from each consignment. 4.2 No qualification for publishers and authors At present, anyone may offer books. There is no requirement of registration, of a real place of business, of a record of selling in the open market, or of proof that the ISBN (the International Standard Book Number, which identifies a book uniquely) belongs to that publisher. There is also no requirement that each author be a real, identifiable person. The 2024 judgment took note of the allegation, placed on record by the petitioner, that “a publisher runs a dozen publications in different names only for the sake of getting Government orders”. It is suggested that only empanelled publishers and authorised distributors be allowed to supply, with empanelment renewed every year. The conditions may be as follows. (a) A legal identity: PAN in the name of the publisher, and proof of constitution. This would be a certificate of incorporation for a company, a registered deed for a partnership, or Udyam registration or a trade licence from the local body for a proprietary concern. The publisher should also have a current account in the firm’s name and should have filed income-tax returns for the last two years. GST registration should not be made a condition. Printed books are exempt from GST, and a person dealing exclusively in exempt supplies is not liable to register under section 23(1)(a) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. GST registration may be asked for only where the publisher also supplies taxable items, such as e-books. (b) A verifiable place of business: This should be checked through documents alone and without any field visit. Field inspection is practicable only within Tamil Nadu, and it brings officials and suppliers into direct contact, which the procedure should avoid. The publisher should upload proof of address: the address on the registration or Udyam certificate, a lease or ownership document, and a recent utility bill. Geo-tagged photographs of the premises and signboard should also be uploaded. The portal should cross-check this address with the addresses on the PAN, the ISBN agency record and the income-tax return. Any mismatch should lead to the application being returned, and a false declaration should be treated as an unfair practice. A small percentage of empanelled publishers may be selected at random by the portal for a fresh desk verification each year. (c) A track record of trading: Publishers with at least 200 titles and at least five years of trading may be placed in the established category. The Directorate is already required by the 2024 judgment to maintain a list of such publishers. Smaller or newer publishers may be admitted in a separate category if they have traded for at least two years and have at least ten titles in the open market, subject to a lower ceiling and closer verification. Genuine small presses should not be shut out. (d) ISBN ownership: The ISBN prefix must be registered in the publisher’s own name. (e) Statutory deposit: Proof of deposit of copies with the Connemara Public Library under the Delivery of Books and Newspapers (Public Libraries) Act, 1954, as the Transparent Book Procurement Policy already contemplates in para 3. (f) Sister imprints: A declaration of the owners and of all sister imprints. Linked imprints should be treated as one group for ceilings, scoring and debarment. (g) Distributors: Letters of authorisation from each publisher whose books they offer. (h) Verification of authors: Two risks need to be covered: a fictitious author, and a book that wrongly carries the name of a real author. The second cannot be detected merely by confirming that the author exists. It must be confirmed that the author actually wrote the book. The verification may be done as follows. (i) Formal author agreements and royalty statements are not common practice in Tamil publishing, and they cannot be obtained for English and international titles. They should not be insisted upon. Instead, the publisher should file a simple declaration for each title. It would give the author’s real name, a short biographical note and the author’s contact details. Where a pen name is used, the real name would be disclosed to the Directorate in confidence. (ii) The portal should check every title against the named author’s known body of work in national and international bibliographic records and in the catalogues of that author’s regular publishers. This check should be automated. (iii) Where a well-known author’s name appears on a title missing from that author’s known works, the title should be flagged. The same applies where such a name appears with a publisher the author has not been associated with before. In these cases, confirmation must not be sought through the contact details given by the applicant publisher, since those can themselves be false. It should be sought in writing by the Directorate through independent channels, such as the author’s institutional e-mail address or the author’s regular publisher. (iv) For other titles of new or small publishers, and for titles flagged in screening, the portal may send an automated message to the author’s declared mobile number or e-mail address seeking confirmation of authorship. This avoids any personal contact. (v) Exemption from the author declaration should not turn on any official’s view of whether a publisher is “established”. The portal should grant it automatically, title by title, only where every one of the following conditions is met: • the publisher is empanelled in the established category under (c), on documentary criteria alone (at least 200 titles and at least five years of trading, verified from the registration certificate and income-tax returns), and has no adverse record under paras 12 or 23 of the Transparent Book Procurement Policy; • the ISBN agency record for the title matches the publisher, the title and the author declared; • the title is held by at least three libraries outside Tamil Nadu, as shown in a national or international union catalogue, or it carries Cataloguing-in-Publication data issued by a national library; • the title has been on sale through at least two independent channels, such as bookshop distributors or online retailers, for at least six months before the date of the call. A title that fails any of these conditions must file the declaration under (i). Every title, exempt or not, remains subject to the automated check in (ii). In the case of n
- impugned order is hereby set aside./ THE HON’BLE MR JUSTICE KRISHNAN RAMASAMY WP No. 36287 of 2024 AND WMP NO. 33941 OF 2026 & 39168 OF 2024 Hemamalini Suresh
- தமிழகம் முழுவதும் காணாமல் போனவர்கள் தொடர்பாக எத்தனை வழக்குகள் பதிவு செய்யப்பட்டுள்ளன?”
More
Recent Posts
- csk fan – personality rights order// THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE P.B. BALAJI OA No. 1229 of 2026, A.Nos.4827 & 4828 of 2026 in C.S(COMM DIV) No. 303 of 2026 CNR:{HCMA012661542026} Saravanan Hari
- Periyar Library case THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE G.R.SWAMINATHAN AND THE HON’BLE MRS.JUSTICE M.D.SUMATHI CONT P(MD) No. 3763 of 2026 CNR:{HCMD011622922026} Ramasubbu
- BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT DATED: 16-11-2026 CORAM THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE G.R.SWAMINATHAN AND THE HON’BLE MRS.JUSTICE M.D.SUMATHI CONT P(MD) No. 3763 of 2026 CNR:{HCMD011622922026} Ramasubbu S/o. Late S. Vijayakumar, Door No.8/18C, Sri Sakthi Nagar, Krishnapuram, Tirunelveli District -627 011. ..Petitioner(s) Vs 1. K.Gopal, IAS, The Secretry to Government, Department of Higher Education, Secretariat, Fort St.George, Chennai. 2. R.V.Shajeevana IAS, Director of Public Libraries, Public Libraries Directorate, 737/1, Anna Salai, Chennai -600 002. ..Respondent(s) Prayer : Contempt Petition filed under Section 11 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 to initiate contempt proceedings against Respondents 1 and 2 for their wilful deliberate, and contumacious disobedience of the directions issued in the Judgment dated 19.06.2024 in W.P. (MD) No. 10150 of 2019 and punish the contemnors/respondents in their personal and official capacities with maximum imprisonment and fine. For Petitioner(s): Mr.K.P.S.Palanivel Rajan, for Mr.P.M.Vishnu Varthanan For Respondent(s): Mr.Vijay Narayan, Advocate General, assisted by, Mr.P.V.Balasubramanian, Additional Advocate General, & Mr.B.Saravanan, Additional Advocate General, assisted by, Mr.M.Kannan, Special Government Pleader. Mr.R.John Sathyan, State Public Prosecutor, assisted by, Mr.D.Venkatesh, Additional Public Prosecutor. ORDER (Order of the Court was made by G.R. SWAMINATHAN J.) Heard the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner and the learned Advocate General, Additional Advocate Generals and the learned State Public Prosecutor. 2. This morning we had posed the following queries:- i) Procurement of books has been categorised into two. a) General and b) special. Procurement for Periyar Arivulagam was under the special category. It may be clarified whether the same principles and conditions governing general procurement was applied to special procurement also. ii) How many days were taken to select and procure the books for Kalaignar Library, Madurai and Periyar Arivulagam? iii) How many books were procured for Kalaignar Library, Madurai (January to December, 2025) and Periyar Arivulagam? iv) When procurement was made in two stages under the Transparency Rules, how many books were rejected by expert committee? How many books rejected by the expert committee were procured for Periyar Arivulagam? v) How many books were recommended by the 137-member expert committee? What was the time granted for this process? How many books were procured? vi) It was submitted on the last occasion that Agalvilakku submitted 2300 and odd titles and that 1700 were selected and procured. Who rejected the 600 titles of Agalvilakku and at what stage? What was the reason for such rejection? Copies of the minutes to be made available. If 600 titles of a publisher could be rejected, what made the officials to select and purchase the remaining 1700? vii) How many English books were purchased for Periyar Arivulagam? Whether directly from publishers or from book sellers? What was the budget allotted for English books and Tamil books respectively? Has the entire budget amount has been utilised? viii) Was the work of the librarians who were appointed as Nodal and Coordinating Officials overseen by the Director of Public Libraries and School Education Secretary? Were the files perused by them? Did the Secretary issue any written instruction? ix) How many books were not procured even though they were recommended by the expert committee? What were the reasons?” 3. When the matter was taken up for hearing in the afternoon, the learned Advocate General submitted that he would need some more time to respond. He assured this Court that all the persons involved in the scam will be dealt with. He added that five officials have already been suspended in connection with this scam. 4. The learned State Public Prosecutor submitted that pursuant to the departmental enquiry as well as the direction given by this Court, DVAC, Chennai City have registered FIR in Crime No. 4 of 2026 for various offences under the BNS as well as the Prevention of Corruption Act. Agalvilakku’s Proprietor Mr.Mohan who figures prominently in the scam has been named as one of the accused. 5. The learned Advocate General submitted that if any suggestion comes from this Court as regards streamlining the future procurement processes, that would definitely be considered by the Government. 6. Thiru. Badrinarayanan Seshadri of Kizhakku Padhippagam, who appeared and assisted this Court as a stakeholder, has sent us a note which has been enclosed with this order as Annexure ‘A’. Two other stake holders who do not want themselves to be named have also placed their suggestions. They are enclosed as Annexures ‘B’ and ‘C’. We expect and hope that the Government will go through all the three notes with utmost care and attention and respond on a positive note by the next hearing date. The earlier guidelines have been rendered toothless. It is time to evolve a foolproof procedure. Since the suggestions are fairly comprehensive, it should not take too long to issue a formal G.O so that we do not witness another scam in books procurement. Once such a binding procedure is put in place, we shall close this contempt petition. We would of course issue suitable directions. 7. We take judicial notice of the fact that library cess is levied and collected. We want to know if the cess amount so collected has been duly credited. We also want to know how the said amount has been spent so far. The affidavit to be filed by the authorities shall devote a paragraph to this aspect also. Some impleading applications have been filed. They will be considered on the next hearing date. 8. The Government would do well to undertake a detailed probe and come out with a statement by the next hearing date as to how procurement of books has taken place for the last twenty years and more. It would be in order if a White paper is submitted. The scam has shaken the conscience of the people of Tamil Nadu. Their faith in the system must be restored. 9. We have expressed such sentiments because two icons of Tamil Nadu, namely, Shri.E.V.Ramaswamy(reverentially called as Periyar) and Shri.C.N.Annadurai (Arignar Anna) have impressed upon us the importance of libraries and general reading. Periyar remarked as follows:- “Schools promote literacy and knowledge in a particular field. But the library fosters awareness of general knowledge in all spheres” “gs;spf;$lq;fs; vOj;jwpitAk;> Fwpg;gpl;l Jiwfspy; mwpitAk; tsh;f;fpd;wd. Mdhy;> E}yfq;fNsh midj;Jj; JiwfspYk; nghJ mwpit tsh;f;fpd;wd.” Anna once famously remarked that the library should be accorded a place next to the basic necessities of life, in the following terms:- “tho;f;ifapy; mbg;gilj; NjitfSf;F mLj;j ,lk; Gj;jfr; rhiyf;F jug;glNtz;Lk;.” 10. We are conscious that the Court should not direct the investigation officer to arrest any particular accused. But the case on hand falls under an exceptional category. The bogus publishers have already been identified. Or at least some of them. Unless they are custodially interrogated, one will never know how much money was paid to which public servant. The modus operandi must be brought out. Unlike the earlier scams, the present one rises not only on scale but also the manner in which it has been committed. For the first time, AI and digital processes have been subverted for achieving sinister ends. Of course, these matters fall within the realm of the police. We are sure that by the next hearing date, we will get a better picture. 11. Call this case on 20.11.2026 at 10.30 a.m., as first item. (G.R.S.,J.) (M.D.S.,J.) 16-11-2026 PMU Encl: Annexures A, B and C. 1. K.Gopal, IAS The Secretry to Government Department of Higher Education Secretariat Fort St.George Chennai 2. R.V.Shajeevana IAS Director of Public Libraries Public Libraries Directorate 737/1, Anna Salai Chennai -600 002 Annexure – A Badrinarayanan Seshadri 3A, Sri Gurukrupa Apartments 7/9, CP Ramaswamy Street Abhiramapuram, Chennai 600018 To HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE G.R. SWAMINATHAN AND HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.D. SUMATHI Madras High Court, Madurai Bench Date: 13/11/2026 Sub: Concerns about procurement of books to public libraries in Tamil Nadu and how the process can be improved Respected Justices, 1. I am Badrinarayanan Seshadri, publisher of Kizhakku Pathippagam, one of the leading Tamil publishers. I have been publishing books in Tamil since 2004. To this day, we have published more than 2500 Tamil titles, most of them nonfiction, covering biographies, political histories, current a^airs, business, finance, economics, self-help, religion, healthcare, history, science and literature. We have also published some fiction, both short stories and novels. 2. I have a B.Tech from IIT Madras and a Ph.D from Cornell University (USA) in the field of Mechanical Engineering. I am a serial entrepreneur, and have run or am running multiple, successful businesses such as Cricinfo (1996-2005), Kizhakku Pathippagam (2004-), Synprosoft (2014-), Argee Sta^ing Services (2018-2022), Ascendency Interlinks (2023-), and Syncretic Media (2025-), in the space of cricket information, Tamil book publishing, software services on Zoho platform, IT sta^ing, BNI franchise and YouTube video content generation. 3. Under Kizhakku Pathippagam, I have not only published books, but also edited many of the titles, written a few books and translated some from English to Tamil. I have also devised strategies for selling these books across Tamil Nadu in every nook and corner including in restaurants, textile shops, supermarkets, grocery stores and even the petty shops and tea shops across small towns and villages. I have been the first to deploy all kinds of new technologies, namely audio books, Kindle e-books, print-on-demand etc. 4. We have always strived to bring the best books to Tamil and have bought translation rights to more than 200 English titles and published their Tamil translations. We have routinely commissioned Tamil books from reputed authors, in a variety of topics and we are proud of the easy readability we have brought into our books, as well as the attractive packaging, cover design, catchy titles, layout clarity etc. 5. We are an ethical publisher. We have never offered bribe in all these 22 years to anyone for the procurement of our books by the Dept of Public Libraries. We have always applied for all our titles and have fulfilled whatever orders we have received, however small they were, without ever complaining. 6. I have been observing the corruption and irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu for the last 22 years. Over this period, I have consistently voiced my concerns through my blogs, newspaper articles, public discussions and videos. The recent controversy involving the procurement of allegedly fraudulent, AIgenerated and falsely attributed books published by Agal Vilakku and other publishers in large numbers for public libraries across Tamil Nadu has deeply disturbed me. It has once again demonstrated how public money can be diverted towards books of questionable authenticity and value, while genuine authors and publishers struggle to have their books acquired by public libraries. 7. To address the systemic flaws that have enabled such irregularities, I would like to offer the following suggestions. Many of these principles have already been articulated in the excellent judgment of the Hon’ble Madras High Court dated 19 June 2024 in W.P.(MD) No. 10150 of 2019 — S. Krishnan vs. The Secretary to Government, Department of Higher Education. That judgment directed the Government to implement its Transparent Book Procurement Policy, publish shortlisted books, invite public objections for one month, preserve those objections, and investigate past procurement irregularities. The subsequent orders dated 10 and 11 November 2026 in Contempt Petition (MD) No. 3763 of 2026 — Ramasubbu vs. K. Gopal, IAS, have further exposed the failure to implement these directions in letter and spirit. Particularly relevant is the observation in the order dated 11 November 2026 that the Directorate should consider publishing a comprehensive record of books procured over the preceding two decades, including titles, quantities and payments. The Court also recorded the importance of disclosing the dates on which publishers submitted their bills and the dates on which payments were settled. Although the Court clarified that this was not yet a formal direction, it is an important recommendation deserving immediate attention. I am therefore restating some of the Court’s recommendations, while adding further suggestions to establish a fair, transparent, efficient and accountable procurement system. I. Transparency and Public Accountability A. Complete transparency in the selection process The entire book selection process, beginning with the invitation for publishers to submit catalogues and books, through evaluation by subject experts, shortlisting, determination of quantities and final approval, must be completely transparent. The names of the selection committee members, the criteria adopted for evaluating books, the individual and consolidated evaluation scores, and the reasons for selecting or rejecting books should be available for public scrutiny. Where an official or committee changes the recommendation of an expert, that change must be documented with the reasons and the authority responsible. The procedures prescribed in the 2024 S. Krishnan judgment should be fully implemented. Merely establishing an online procurement portal cannot be considered sufficient compliance unless the actual decisions made through that system are transparent. B. Public right to review and criticise book selections As directed in the 2024 judgment, the complete list of shortlisted books, including their titles, authors, publishers, cover images, prices and proposed quantities, must be made available for public examination. The public, including readers, authors, publishers, librarians and subject experts, should be allowed at least one month to submit comments, criticisms and objections. All such comments must remain publicly accessible and should never be deleted merely because they are critical of the Directorate or its decisions. Before finalising procurement, the authorities should publish their responses to substantive objections, explaining why the relevant books have been retained, removed or otherwise reconsidered. This will ensure that public consultation is meaningful rather than a procedural formality. C. Public disclosure of purchase orders, supplies and payments The Directorate should maintain a publicly accessible database containing complete information about every book procured using public funds. For every title, the database should disclose: • ISBN, book title, author, publisher, edition and original publication year. • Number of copies ordered and the libraries for which they are intended. • Printed price, negotiated price, discount and total purchase value. • Date of issue of the purchase order. • Date of delivery and acceptance of the books. • Date of submission of the publisher’s or supplier’s invoice. • Date of approval and actual release of payment. The proposed purchase orders should be published before final approval, and the final purchase orders, delivery records and payments should be disclosed as the procurement progresses. The information should be available in searchable and downloadable formats, including CSV or Excel, rather than only as scanned documents. Historical disclosure: The Directorate should also publish a consolidated database of book procurement for the preceding 20 years, to the extent that records are available, with missing records clearly identified. This will make it possible to identify unusual procurement patterns, excessive concentration of orders among particular publishers, repeated purchases of the same books and preferential payment practices. In particular, allegations have been made that certain publishers, including Agal Vilakku, received preferential treatment both in the quantity of books ordered and the speed with which their payments were processed. Publication of the underlying records will help establish the facts objectively. Such disclosure, by itself, can become one of the strongest safeguards against favouritism and corruption. D. Preservation of a complete digital audit trail Every action performed through the book procurement portal must be preserved in a secure, tamper-evident digital audit trail. This should include the original submissions made by publishers, expert evaluations, scores, recommendations, changes made by officials, approvals, purchase orders and payment authorisations. No recommendation or score should be altered without preserving the earlier version, the identity of the person making the change, the date and time, and the reason for the modification. Periodic independent technical audits should verify that the books finally ordered are the same books that were evaluated, shortlisted and approved through the prescribed process. This would help prevent manipulation of procurement decisions after the expert evaluation stage. II. Institutional Accountability and Prevention of Corruption E. Disclosure of publisher ownership and conflicts of interest Every publisher and distributor participating in library procurement should disclose the identity of its legal owners, beneficial owners, partners, directors and related publishing entities. Where multiple publishing houses operate under different names but have common ownership or control, such relationships should be made public. This is necessary to identify instances where the same individuals may be using multiple imprints to secure a disproportionate share of government procurement. Members of selection committees, expert panels and procurement authorities should also disclose material financial, professional or familial relationships with publishers, authors or distributors whose books they evaluate. Persons having such conflicts of interest must recuse themselves from the relevant decisions. Deliberate concealment of material relationships should attract appropriate disqualification and disciplinary consequences. F. Independent annual audit of procurement There should be an annual independent audit of the entire book procurement process. This audit should examine the selection of titles, compliance with evaluation procedures, quantities purchased, pricing, discounts, delivery records, payments and possible conflicts of interest. Random physical verification should be undertaken at public libraries to establish whether the books recorded as delivered were actually received and are available for borrowing. The audit report and the Government’s action-taken report should be made public every year. In view of the recent controversy, a special forensic audit of procurement over the preceding five years should also be considered. Its objective should be to identify systemic irregularities, quantify financial losses where established, and determine responsibility for fraudulent transactions. G. Public grievance redressal mechanism A permanent, independent grievance redressal mechanism should be established for authors, publishers, librarians, readers and members of the public. Complaints may concern unfair exclusion of books, questionable selection, inflated prices, plagiarism, fabricated authorship, unauthorised translations, copyright violations, procurement manipulation or corruption. Every complaint should be acknowledged within seven days and ordinarily disposed of through a reasoned decision within 30 days, with an extension permitted for complex cases. An appellate mechanism should be available, particularly where the complaint concerns officials of the Directorate itself. Reasonable safeguards should be provided to protect complainants and whistleblowers against retaliation, while preventing misuse through knowingly false complaints. III. Decentralisation and Better Use of Library Funds H. Local versus centralised book procurement Keralam offers an example of a more decentralised approach in which local library institutions exercise considerable discretion over their collections. Local librarians are often better positioned to understand the interests, reading habits, language preferences and educational needs of their communities than officials making purchase decisions centrally. Tamil Nadu may consider adopting a hybrid procurement model under which 50% of the available procurement funds are allocated to individual libraries for local selection and 50% are retained for centralised procurement. This could initially be implemented as a pilot programme across selected districts and subsequently expanded after evaluating its effectiveness. Clear guidelines should provide for the participation of local librarians, library users, local government representatives and community members in the selection process. Local libraries should be permitted to acquire books outside the centrally approved shortlist, subject to transparent procedures, reasonable price controls and appropriate audit requirements. Centralised procurement should continue to serve purposes such as statewide acquisitions, significant reference collections, specialised works and titles that benefit from bulk purchasing. Decentralisation must not merely transfer the opportunity for corruption from the State level to the local level. The same transparency and accountability standards should apply to both systems. I. Encouraging donations of books to libraries The present process of donating books to public libraries is unnecessarily difficult and discourages individuals and institutions who wish to contribute to public education and I have personally experienced this problem. A donor was willing to purchase 2,000 copies of a few important books published by Kizhakku Pathippagam and donate them to public libraries in Tamil Nadu. Despite approaching the library authorities, we could not obtain a meaningful response. Consequently, a valuable opportunity was lost. The Directorate of Public Libraries should establish a formal policy for accepting donations of books, supported by a permanent committee empowered to evaluate such offers. Every proposal should receive a written acceptance or rejection within 30 days, with reasons. The policy should allow the evaluation of a representative set of donated titles rather than imposing unnecessary administrative requirements on donors. Donation procedures must also ensure that libraries are not compelled to accept unsuitable or unwanted books, and that donor interests do not compromise collection quality. A transparent donation policy would encourage philanthropists, publishers, institutions, foundations and individuals to contribute meaningfully to the public library system. J. Reader preferences, actual usage and procurement planning Book procurement should ultimately be assessed by how effectively public libraries serve their readers, not merely by the number of titles purchased or the amount of money spent. The Directorate should collect and periodically publish aggregate information regarding circulation, reader requests, frequently borrowed titles, underused books and unmet demand. Library users should have a simple mechanism to recommend books for acquisition. These data should inform future purchasing decisions, particularly at the local level. However, circulation statistics should not become the sole criterion for selection. Important works of history, philosophy, literature, science and cultural heritage may deserve a place in public libraries even when their immediate readership is limited. The privacy of individual borrowers must also be protected. Public reporting should be based on aggregate usage data, not identifiable borrowing histories. IV. More Efficient and Economical Procurement Models K. Nationalised works, public-domain books and duplicate purchases Tamil Nadu has a distinguished tradition of nationalising literary works, making important books more widely accessible to the public. However, the procurement of nationalised and public-domain works has also created opportunities for wasteful expenditure and fraudulent repackaging. The same works are frequently published by different publishers, sometimes with new covers, modified titles or misleading attribution, and repeatedly procured for libraries. A familiar example is Kalki’s Ponniyin Selvan, which is available in numerous editions from different publishers. Such purchases can crowd out other valuable books and deprive contemporary writers and publishers of opportunities to reach library readers. For standard nationalised works, the Government should consider preparing or approving authoritative editions and inviting competitive tenders for printing, binding and delivery. This would enable the Government to procure large numbers of copies at substantially lower costs, while maintaining appropriate standards of textual accuracy, printing and binding. At the same time, genuine new translations, critical editions, annotated versions, scholarly introductions and materially improved editions should continue to be eligible for procurement. A central bibliographic database should help identify substantial duplication, including works republished under different titles, names or ISBNs. The objective should be to prevent wasteful repetition and misrepresentation, not to discourage legitimate publishing activity. L. Procurement of educational, academic and reference books from national and international publishers For educational, academic, scientific and reference books published by national and international publishers, the Directorate should first identify the required titles and editions through an appropriate expert selection process. Once the titles and quantities are finalised, procurement should be undertaken through competitive tendering among authorised booksellers and distributors. These suppliers would be able to aggregate orders, negotiate discounts with publishers and offer competitive prices for procurement and delivery. The tender process should consider the final delivered price, including applicable taxes, shipping and handling charges, and should verify that the supplier is authorised to provide the relevant editions. This would be more efficient and transparent than relying on individual discretionary purchase arrangements. Where exclusive distribution rights or other legitimate constraints prevent competition, the reasons for adopting an alternative procurement method should be documented and disclosed. M. Procurement and lending of e-books A growing number of Tamil publishers have begun releasing books in digital formats. The Government should evolve a comprehensive policy for acquiring, licensing and lending Tamil e-books through the public library network. Residents of Tamil Nadu should be able to register with the public library system and borrow eligible e-books through an online platform, broadly comparable in user experience to commercial digital reading services such as Kindle Unlimited or Everand. A dedicated annual fund should be established for procuring or licensing digital books. Publishers may be compensated through a combination of agreed licensing fees and verified usage-based payments, taking into account actual borrowing and reading activity. Appropriate safeguards should prevent manipulation of download counts, artificial reading activity and other forms of fraudulent claims. The policy must address copyright, digital lending rights, accessibility, data privacy, reasonable lending limits and fair compensation to authors and publishers. In addition to widening access, a well-designed e-book lending system could significantly benefit readers in rural areas and smaller towns who may not have ready access to large physical collections. V. Publishing Integrity and Enforcement N. Undertakings by publishers and authors regarding authenticity, copyright and AI-generated content Every publisher supplying books to public libraries must provide a legally enforceable undertaking concerning the authenticity, authorship and copyright status of the books submitted. The publisher must certify that: 1. Every named author is a real and identifiable person who has authorised publication of the work. 2. The publisher possesses the necessary rights to publish and supply the book. 3. The work does not contain plagiarised material, fabricated authorship, deliberately falsified content or unauthorised reproduction of copyrighted works. 4. In the case of translations, the necessary translation rights have been obtained from the original copyright holder wherever such permission is legally required. 5. The work has been subjected to appropriate editorial and factual scrutiny, and the publisher accepts responsibility for the authenticity of the submitted publication. 6. Any substantial use of generative AI in producing the substantive content of the book has been disclosed, distinguishing such use from ordinary editorial assistance, proofreading, indexing or other supporting functions. Publishers should, in turn, obtain appropriate declarations from the respective authors, translators and editors. The intention is not to prohibit legitimate technological assistance in publishing, but to prevent the supply of fraudulent, fabricated, plagiarised or falsely attributed books in the guise of genuine literary or scholarly publications. Consequences of violation If a book is found, after appropriate verification and due process, to violate these undertakings, the publisher should be required to withdraw all affected copies supplied to public libraries at its own expense and refund the amounts received from the Government. Additional penalties may be imposed according to the nature and seriousness of the violation. Deliberate or repeated serious fraud should attract long-term or permanent debarment from future government procurement, following notice and an opportunity to respond. Where criminal offences are disclosed, appropriate prosecution should follow. These safeguards should apply equally to books in Tamil, English and other languages. O. Time-bound implementation and continuing public oversight One of the most disturbing aspects of the current controversy is that many of the necessary safeguards were already prescribed in the 2024 High Court judgment. The subsequent events indicate that the mere existence of a policy, government order or online portal is insufficient. The Government should therefore publish a time-bound implementation roadmap for all the reforms proposed above. The roadmap should specify the responsibility of the relevant department or official, the implementation deadline, and measurable criteria for determining compliance. Quarterly public reports should disclose the progress of reforms, procurement expenditure, audit findings, complaints received and resolved, and corrective measures undertaken. An annual review involving independent experts, authors, publishers, librarians and representatives of library users should examine whether the procurement system is genuinely serving the public interest. The implementation reports should be permanently accessible on the Directorate’s website. The ultimate purpose of public library procurement is not to provide business opportunities to publishers or distributors, but to make the best possible books available to the people of Tamil Nadu through the efficient and fair use of public funds. A transparent procurement system should simultaneously protect public money, encourage genuine authors and publishers, preserve our literary and intellectual heritage, and respond to the needs of readers. Tamil Nadu has a rich publishing tradition and an extensive public library network. It should be possible for the State to establish a model procurement system that other States in India would wish to emulate. The recent controversy should therefore be treated not merely as an isolated incident requiring investigation and punishment, but as an opportunity to undertake lasting structural reform. I request the Government to initiate a time-bound consultation with publishers, authors, librarians, readers and independent experts, and implement the necessary reforms with clear provisions for transparency, accountability and independent oversight. Above all, the Government must ensure that the rules and procedures prescribed for transparent procurement are implemented in practice, and that compliance can be independently verified by the public. Annexure – B Strengthening Book Procurement for Public Libraries in Tamil Nadu Supplementary safeguards under the Transparent Book Procurement Policy 2024 and a proposal for a High Level Expert Committee Note for Government consideration Part I Existing policy and the need for supplementary safeguards 1. Existing policy framework The Government of Tamil Nadu has established a comprehensive framework for transparent procurement of books for public libraries through the Transparent Book Procurement Policy, 2024, issued in G.O.(Ms) No.69, School Education Department, dated 07.03.2024. The policy provides for online applications, bibliographic particulars and review copies, point-based evaluation by subject experts, participation of librarians and readers, quality verification, a Book Price Index, online price negotiation, and procedures for ordering, supply and payment. It also addresses personal bias and unfair practices, including alteration of titles or authors’ names, unauthorised reproduction, manipulation of publication particulars, artificial inflation of page counts and supply of inferior books. 2. Compliance with existing requirements The first requirement is consistent implementation of the existing policy in its entirety. Every prescribed safeguard shall be supported by a verifiable administrative process, a designated responsible authority, supporting records and supervisory checks. The High Court’s judgment dated 19.06.2024 in W.P.(MD) No.10150 of 2019 additionally requires procurement in consonance with the policy, a functional public portal, publication of shortlisted books with relevant particulars and covers, and a month’s opportunity for public remarks and objections before finalisation. These are existing compliance obligations and shall be incorporated into the procurement calendar. 3. Need for further strengthening Concerns relating to fabricated publications, fictitious authorship, misuse of bibliographic identifiers, undisclosed machine-generated content and manipulation of digital selection records warrant a focused review. The exercise shall distinguish failures in implementation, procedural gaps requiring clarification, and emerging risks requiring policy amendments. The existing framework may accordingly be preserved and strengthened through targeted supplementary safeguards. Part II Additional safeguards proposed for consideration 4. Authenticity of content and disclosure of AI use Every application may carry a title-specific declaration from the publisher, supported by the author or authorised rights holder wherever reasonably obtainable, confirming the authenticity of authorship, lawful entitlement to publish and supply, and absence of undisclosed reproduction or substantial recycling of other works. The declaration shall disclose whether generative artificial intelligence was used to produce substantive text, translations, illustrations or other material content, and the nature and extent of that use. The policy may distinguish assistance in spelling, formatting or language editing from substantive machine generation presented misleadingly as original human authorship. The declaration should establish responsibility for the work rather than depend upon an unverifiable blanket certification that no AI tool was used at any stage. 5. Technical screening and expert verification A documented screening procedure may identify duplicated text, fabricated references, repetitive or incoherent material, false attribution and substantially identical content submitted under different titles. Automated plagiarism and AI-detection tools may assist in identifying titles requiring closer examination; a software score shall not, by itself, constitute proof of fabrication or a sufficient ground for rejection or penal action. Flagged titles may be referred to an independent content-verification panel for a reasoned assessment. Copying, scanning and processing of review material shall be subject to appropriate copyright permissions and confidentiality safeguards. 6. ISBN and bibliographic verification The requirement that a book carry an ISBN may be supplemented by verification, through the competent ISBN agency or other authoritative records, of its association with the relevant publisher, title, edition and format, to the extent records are available. A valid ISBN shall not be treated as certification of originality, factual accuracy, literary merit or freedom from AI-generated content. Reused, inconsistent or apparently fabricated identifiers shall be clarified before selection. 7. Verification of publishers, authors and connected entities Proportionate documentary requirements may establish the legal identity, business address, ownership and supply authorisation of applicants. Publishers may disclose sister concerns, related imprints and entities under common ownership or control, enabling detection of attempts to circumvent procurement limits or debarment orders. Independent authorship confirmation may be sought where impersonation or false attribution is suspected. Genuine pen names and confidential particulars shall receive appropriate protection. Credible new and small publishers shall be permitted to participate; absence of a large catalogue or long trading history shall not, by itself, establish lack of genuineness. 8. Evidence of publication and availability Independent catalogues, publisher records, bookseller listings, library holdings and reviews may corroborate a title’s existence and publication history. Absence from commercial platforms may warrant verification but shall not automatically disqualify a genuine new publication, specialist work, small-press edition or work intended for a limited readership. 9. Adequate review time and recorded assessment Reasonable review periods, manageable allocations of titles and a standard assessment format may be prescribed. Each title shall have a traceable record of assigned reviewers, completed assessment, scores and decision. Titles awaiting substantive evaluation shall be carried forward rather than cleared merely to meet expenditure or inauguration deadlines. Interest declarations and recusal shall cover financial, professional and publishing relationships capable of affecting impartial assessment. 10. Integrity of the digital selection process The portal may provide separate permissions for recommendation, evaluation, selection, approval and payment; authenticated approval and locking of lists at each stage; tamper-evident logs of additions, deletions and alterations; and reconciliation between expert recommendations, approved titles, orders, deliveries and payments. No title shall enter the final list without prescribed scrutiny. Subsequent additions shall undergo the same applicable process, with their origin and approval recorded. 11. Public scrutiny and disposal of objections The judicial requirement of public display may be operationalised through procedures for publication, acknowledgement, independent examination, reasoned disposal and retention of objections. Published particulars may include the title, author, publisher, ISBN, edition, cover, proposed quantity and procurement price. Objections shall be decided before finalisation. Public disclosure shall include safeguards against exposure of personal information, unlawful material and unsupported personal allegations. 12. Price scrutiny and enhanced approval The Book Price Index and online negotiation requirements may be supplemented by scrutiny of the net price payable against comparable editions, production specifications and independently verifiable market prices. High-value titles, unusually large orders, exceptional prices and substantial concentration within a connected publisher group may require independent appraisal and higher approval. Thresholds, approving authorities and permissible exceptions shall be prescribed in advance. Exceptions shall carry recorded reasons, particularly for specialist reference works, imported publications and accessible formats. 13. Inspection, payment and remedies after supply Inspection may extend beyond paper, printing and binding to sample verification that supplied content corresponds to the reviewed and approved edition. Supply conditions may provide for replacement, rejection, withholding of the disputed portion of payment and recovery of amounts paid for established misrepresentation or non-conforming supply, subject to applicable law and contractual terms. Recovery through any statutory mechanism shall first be examined for legal authority. Debarment shall follow notice, opportunity to respond and a reasoned order, with its scope and duration proportionate to established misconduct. Criminal referral may be made where verified facts disclose a suspected offence; it shall not follow automatically from an adverse software flag. 14. Initial collections for new and special libraries For newly established or special libraries involving large initial collections, a dedicated Standard Operating Procedure may incorporate the applicable safeguards of the 2024 policy and judicial directions. It may recognise expert-led collection building across subjects while requiring recorded evaluation, price scrutiny, public disclosure and traceability of every approved title. 15. Demand aggregation and continuing oversight Minimum aggregate order quantities may be examined against actual demand, delivery costs and collection diversity. Any threshold shall accommodate specialist, minority-language, local-history and accessible-format publications. Periodic procurement audits, sample content audits, supplier-concentration analysis and publication of title-wise expenditure and payment particulars may be introduced to identify recurring weaknesses. Part III Proposed High Level Expert Committee 16. Constitution and composition Government may consider a compact High Level Expert Committee to review the existing policy, its implementation and the accompanying reform suggestions. An indicative composition is set out below. Chairperson: An eminent serving or retired civil servant with substantial administrative experience and recognised engagement with literature, education or public institutions. Government may consider a person such as Thiru V. Irai Anbu, IAS (Retd.), or Thiru T. Udhayachandran, IAS, subject to consent, availability and applicable administrative requirements. Literary member: An eminent writer of recognised standing, such as Professor Perumal Murugan, subject to consent and disclosure of relevant interests. Publishing member: A representative of a reputed publishing institution with substantial editorial and production experience, selected through objective criteria. Library member: A senior library professional experienced in collection development, cataloguing and public-library administration. Technical member: An independent expert in digital audit, information security or content verification. The Directorate may provide secretarial assistance. Finance, Law and other specialists may be invited for specific matters without enlarging permanent membership. 17. Terms of reference (i) Undertake a clause-wise review of the 2024 policy, relevant Government Orders,operational guidelines and applicable judicial directions. (ii) Distinguish implementation deficiencies from gaps in policy design. (iii) Examine the accompanying suggestions and identify measures already prescribed,measures requiring clarification and measures requiring amendment. (iv) Recommend safeguards against fabricated content, false authorship, ISBN misuse,plagiarism, undisclosed substantive AI generation and manipulation of digital records. (v) Define practical responsibilities for publishers, reviewers, librarians, approvingauthorities and payment officers. (vi) Recommend a separate SOP for large initial procurements for new libraries. (vii) Review exceptional procurement routes, high-value approvals, supplier concentrationand conflict-of-interest controls. (viii) Submit draft amendments, standard declarations, inspection formats and animplementation plan specifying authorities and timelines. 18. Independence and scope Members shall disclose relevant interests and abstain from matters affecting their publications, publishing institutions, financial interests or transactions in which they previously participated. The mandate shall concern systemic reform. It shall not substitute for, interfere with or prejudge judicial, vigilance, disciplinary or criminal proceedings. Individual culpability shall remain for determination by the competent authorities. 19. Time frame and deliverables The Committee may submit interim recommendations within thirty days and its final report within ninety days of constitution. A comparative statement may set out each existing provision, identified deficiency, proposed amendment or instruction, implementing authority and means of verifying compliance. Government may thereafter issue necessary amendments and instructions with appropriate legal and financial vetting. 20. Proposal for Government consideration Government may constitute the above High Level Expert Committee to examine the Transparent Book Procurement Policy, 2024, together with the accompanying reform suggestions, and recommend supplementary measures necessary to secure its effective implementation in letter and spirit. The review shall aim to apply public funds to genuine and useful publications through a transparent, accountable and verifiable process, while supporting literary diversity and fair participation by credible publishers. Documents referred to 1. Transparent Book Procurement Policy 2024, supplied policy document; G.O.(Ms) No.69, School EducationDepartment, dated 07.03.2024. 2. Reform of Book Procurement for Public Libraries in Tamil Nadu – A Note of Suggestions, supplied draft. 3. S. Krishnan v. The Secretary to Government, W.P.(MD) No.10150 of 2019, judgment dated 19.06.2024, particularlyparagraph 12. Annexure – C Reform of Book Procurement for Public Libraries in Tamil Nadu: A 1. Purpose of this note 1.1 This note sets out suggestions for reforming the procurement of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu. It takes into account two decisions of the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court. The first is the judgment dated 19.06.2024 in W.P.(MD) No.10150 of 2019 (referred to below as “the 2024 judgment”). The second is the order dated 11.11.2026 in Cont.P.(MD) No.3763 of 2026, which arises out of it (referred to below as “the contempt order”). 1.2 Two different kinds of procurement are involved, so the suggestions are in two parts: (a) Part I: The one-time procurement of a large collection, of one lakh books or more, for newly established special libraries. This is at present done through the committees constituted under G.O.(Ms) No.250, School Education Department, dated 05.11.2025. (b) Part II: The continuous procurement of additions for the existing public libraries. This is governed by the Transparent Book Procurement Policy, 2024, issued in G.O.(Ms) No.69, School Education Department, dated 07.03.2024 (referred to below as “the Transparent Book Procurement Policy”). 1.3 In the 2024 judgment, the High Court observed that “time has come to put in place proper mechanism for such procurement”. It directed that procurement be in line with G.O.(Ms) No.69 and that a dedicated website be maintained. It also directed that every shortlist be published, with the book cover, for a month of remarks and objections before the procurement is finalised. In the contempt order, the Court has recorded that “bound stationery passing for books” has been purchased for various public libraries. 1.4 The suggestions, in brief, are as follows. (a) For special libraries: a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for one-time collection building. It would bring in the good practices of the Transparent Book Procurement Policy together with the transparency directions of the Court, and would be issued along with the Government Order sanctioning each new library. (b) For existing libraries: amendments to the Transparent Book Procurement Policy so that it deals with machine-generated content (including an immediate red flag by reviewers), the qualification of publishers and authors, adequate time for review, a minimum order quantity for each title, and the publication of the shortlist for claims and objections. (c) Common to both: a declaration by the publisher and screening for AI-generated content; a check that each book is actually sold in the open market; verification of the publisher and the author; a mandatory minimum time for review; expert scoring recorded title by title; a price ceiling based on the Book Price Index; a limit on the share of any one publisher; publication of the shortlist for thirty days; a content check before payment and a clause for recovery afterwards. 2. New libraries and existing libraries: why two procedures 2.1 Adding books to a library that already exists is different from stocking a new library from an empty building. The first is a small, regular addition to a collection that is already balanced. The second is the planning and purchase of an entire collection, across every subject, in a single round. The two differ in scale, in who chooses the books, and in where the titles come from. That is why two separate procedures have come into use. Existing libraries New special libraries Libraries covered More than 4,500 district central, branch, village and part-time libraries Periyar Arivulagam (Coimbatore), Kamarajar Arivulagam (Tiruchirappalli), Bharathidasan Arivulagam (Salem), Anjalai Ammal Arivulagam (Cuddalore), Quaid-e-Millath Arivulagam (Tirunelveli), and new district central libraries Nature of purchase Continuous additions and replacements, every quarter One-time purchase of a complete collection, one lakh titles or more Source of funds Library cess, of which up to 25% is used for reading material (Transparent Book Procurement Policy, paras 11 and 15) One-time grant. G.O.(Ms) No.250 provides ₹136 crore in all for books and e-books How titles come in Publishers apply online, book by book, and each book is evaluated and scored Subject experts identify the best titles from syllabi, reference lists, award lists and the catalogues of Indian and foreign publishers Who decides for each library Readers’ circle and librarian, choosing from an approved list (Transparent Book Procurement Policy, para 16) Committees decide centrally for the whole collection Existing libraries New special libraries Range Mainly Tamil; general reading and competitive-examination books Tamil and English, academic and research titles, children’s books, Braille and audio books, e-books and e-journals 2.2 Why the Transparent Book Procurement Policy alone is not enough for a new library: The Transparent Book Procurement Policy depends on publishers applying, title by title. A researchgrade collection of a lakh titles cannot be built that way. Many of the books it must hold are never offered by their publishers: international academic titles, reference works, award winners and government or research publications. Someone has to go looking for them, subject by subject, and that is work only subject experts can do. This is why G.O.(Ms) No.250 created a 137-member Book Recommendation Committee and a 13-member Book Selection Committee. 2.3 Why the committees still need the safeguards of the Transparent Book Procurement Policy: A large one-time purchase is more open to abuse than routine additions. The volume is large, the time is usually short, and a single order can be worth lakhs to one supplier. The safeguards developed in the Transparent Book Procurement Policy therefore matter even more here: scoring, a price ceiling, online negotiation and display of the list. 2.4 Suggested approach: The Transparent Book Procurement Policy is designed for continuous procurement, and G.O.(Ms) No.250 for a one-time purchase. Merging the two into a single framework is therefore not advisable. It is suggested instead that a Standard Operating Procedure for one-time collection building be framed. It would carry over all the good practices of the Transparent Book Procurement Policy, with the changes needed for bulk selection, and include the transparency directions of the Court. The SOP would be issued along with the scheme Government Order for each new library, so that the committees have a fixed procedure to follow from the first day. Its contents are set out in Part I. Part I: Special libraries (one-time procurement of a large collection) 3. The present four-committee process 3.1 G.O.(Ms) No.250 sanctions ₹50 crore each for Coimbatore and Tiruchirappalli, ₹10 crore each for Salem, Cuddalore and Tirunelveli, and ₹1 crore each for six new district central libraries, to buy books and e-books. It constitutes four committees, which work one after another. The Director of Public Libraries coordinates all four. (a) Book Recommendation Committee: with 137 members, about three for each subject. It is made up of professors, writers and specialists in more than fifty subjects. Its task is to recommend the best books in each field. This is the only stage at which a subject expert is meant to look at the book itself. (b) Book Selection Committee: with 13 members. It evaluates the recommended titles and finalises a priority list in five streams: Tamil, English, academic, children’s, and books for the (c) Book Procurement Price Negotiation Committee: with 5 members, all officials of the Directorate and the Finance Department. It negotiates directly with publishers and sellers for the highest discount. (d) High Level Committee: with 5 members. It is chaired by the Principal Secretary to Government, School Education Department, and the Director of Public Libraries is its MemberSecretary. It approves the titles, the number of copies and the prices. 3.2 Annexure I to the G.O. lists the sources from which titles may be drawn. These include online bookstores and review sites, reviews in the media, the reading lists of national universities, catalogues sent by publishers and sellers, bestseller lists and literary awards. 3.3 As a design, the sequence of experts first, then selection, then price, then approval is sound. The weakness is that the G.O. constitutes the committees but lays down no procedure for them. It does not say what each committee must check, in what order, on what record, within what time, or what follows if a stage is skipped. The loopholes discussed below follow from this. 4. Loopholes in special-library procurement and suggested remedies 4.0 The facts recorded in the contempt order show how far the existing safeguards failed. One supplier is said to have offered 2,335 titles, of which 1,700 were selected, and it was paid about ₹17 lakh. An established publisher with hundreds of titles received an order for about ₹23,000. The Court remarked that when not even one book of that supplier is seen in the market, it is difficult to understand how no one’s suspicion was aroused. Whether the experts approved these books, or the books were inserted into the lists at the digital stage without the experts’ knowledge, is under investigation. In either case, the procedure did not prevent it. The loopholes are discussed below, each followed by the remedy suggested for it. 4.1 No check on whether the content is genuine G.O.(Ms) No.250 does not ask whether a book was actually written by a person, whether it reads coherently, or whether its facts are correct. Software can now produce book-length text in a matter of minutes, under any number of titles and author names. A book judged by its title, its cover and a few pages can pass through a committee unnoticed. Full digital texts cannot be demanded as a remedy. Publishers, particularly reputed Tamil, English and foreign publishing houses, will not part with them, for reasons of copyright. A layered check is suggested instead, built on what is practicable: (a) Declaration: For every title, the publisher should declare whether AI software was used in writing, translating or editing it, and to what extent. A false declaration should be treated as an unfair practice, leading to debarment and criminal action. (b) Automated screening of the review copy: The Directorate may scan a fixed number of pages, chosen at random from different parts of the printed review copy, solely for screening and under an undertaking of confidentiality. Where the publisher already offers a digital preview, that may be used. The pages would be compared with all other submissions, to catch the same text recycled under different titles and author names, and with the digitised nationalised works held by Government. They would also be checked with AI-detection tools. A flag only marks the title for closer verification. It is not by itself a ground for rejection, since no tool is fully reliable, particularly for Tamil. (c) Market-existence test: It should be verified whether the book is actually sold in bookshops or online, when it was first published, and whether it has been reviewed or catalogued anywhere. A book printed only for a Government order is a warning sign. (d) Verification of flagged titles: Subject experts are eminent persons serving in an honorary capacity, and they cannot be required to read every book in full. A separate Content Verification Panel may therefore be engaged, made up of retired teachers, research scholars and librarians and paid per title. It would read the flagged titles and report before they go to the experts for scoring. (e) Check on delivery: Librarians should compare the delivered copy with the review copy, and the Verification Panel should examine a random sample of titles from each consignment. 4.2 No qualification for publishers and authors At present, anyone may offer books. There is no requirement of registration, of a real place of business, of a record of selling in the open market, or of proof that the ISBN (the International Standard Book Number, which identifies a book uniquely) belongs to that publisher. There is also no requirement that each author be a real, identifiable person. The 2024 judgment took note of the allegation, placed on record by the petitioner, that “a publisher runs a dozen publications in different names only for the sake of getting Government orders”. It is suggested that only empanelled publishers and authorised distributors be allowed to supply, with empanelment renewed every year. The conditions may be as follows. (a) A legal identity: PAN in the name of the publisher, and proof of constitution. This would be a certificate of incorporation for a company, a registered deed for a partnership, or Udyam registration or a trade licence from the local body for a proprietary concern. The publisher should also have a current account in the firm’s name and should have filed income-tax returns for the last two years. GST registration should not be made a condition. Printed books are exempt from GST, and a person dealing exclusively in exempt supplies is not liable to register under section 23(1)(a) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. GST registration may be asked for only where the publisher also supplies taxable items, such as e-books. (b) A verifiable place of business: This should be checked through documents alone and without any field visit. Field inspection is practicable only within Tamil Nadu, and it brings officials and suppliers into direct contact, which the procedure should avoid. The publisher should upload proof of address: the address on the registration or Udyam certificate, a lease or ownership document, and a recent utility bill. Geo-tagged photographs of the premises and signboard should also be uploaded. The portal should cross-check this address with the addresses on the PAN, the ISBN agency record and the income-tax return. Any mismatch should lead to the application being returned, and a false declaration should be treated as an unfair practice. A small percentage of empanelled publishers may be selected at random by the portal for a fresh desk verification each year. (c) A track record of trading: Publishers with at least 200 titles and at least five years of trading may be placed in the established category. The Directorate is already required by the 2024 judgment to maintain a list of such publishers. Smaller or newer publishers may be admitted in a separate category if they have traded for at least two years and have at least ten titles in the open market, subject to a lower ceiling and closer verification. Genuine small presses should not be shut out. (d) ISBN ownership: The ISBN prefix must be registered in the publisher’s own name. (e) Statutory deposit: Proof of deposit of copies with the Connemara Public Library under the Delivery of Books and Newspapers (Public Libraries) Act, 1954, as the Transparent Book Procurement Policy already contemplates in para 3. (f) Sister imprints: A declaration of the owners and of all sister imprints. Linked imprints should be treated as one group for ceilings, scoring and debarment. (g) Distributors: Letters of authorisation from each publisher whose books they offer. (h) Verification of authors: Two risks need to be covered: a fictitious author, and a book that wrongly carries the name of a real author. The second cannot be detected merely by confirming that the author exists. It must be confirmed that the author actually wrote the book. The verification may be done as follows. (i) Formal author agreements and royalty statements are not common practice in Tamil publishing, and they cannot be obtained for English and international titles. They should not be insisted upon. Instead, the publisher should file a simple declaration for each title. It would give the author’s real name, a short biographical note and the author’s contact details. Where a pen name is used, the real name would be disclosed to the Directorate in confidence. (ii) The portal should check every title against the named author’s known body of work in national and international bibliographic records and in the catalogues of that author’s regular publishers. This check should be automated. (iii) Where a well-known author’s name appears on a title missing from that author’s known works, the title should be flagged. The same applies where such a name appears with a publisher the author has not been associated with before. In these cases, confirmation must not be sought through the contact details given by the applicant publisher, since those can themselves be false. It should be sought in writing by the Directorate through independent channels, such as the author’s institutional e-mail address or the author’s regular publisher. (iv) For other titles of new or small publishers, and for titles flagged in screening, the portal may send an automated message to the author’s declared mobile number or e-mail address seeking confirmation of authorship. This avoids any personal contact. (v) Exemption from the author declaration should not turn on any official’s view of whether a publisher is “established”. The portal should grant it automatically, title by title, only where every one of the following conditions is met: • the publisher is empanelled in the established category under (c), on documentary criteria alone (at least 200 titles and at least five years of trading, verified from the registration certificate and income-tax returns), and has no adverse record under paras 12 or 23 of the Transparent Book Procurement Policy; • the ISBN agency record for the title matches the publisher, the title and the author declared; • the title is held by at least three libraries outside Tamil Nadu, as shown in a national or international union catalogue, or it carries Cataloguing-in-Publication data issued by a national library; • the title has been on sale through at least two independent channels, such as bookshop distributors or online retailers, for at least six months before the date of the call. A title that fails any of these conditions must file the declaration under (i). Every title, exempt or not, remains subject to the automated check in (ii). In the case of n
- impugned order is hereby set aside./ THE HON’BLE MR JUSTICE KRISHNAN RAMASAMY WP No. 36287 of 2024 AND WMP NO. 33941 OF 2026 & 39168 OF 2024 Hemamalini Suresh
- தமிழகம் முழுவதும் காணாமல் போனவர்கள் தொடர்பாக எத்தனை வழக்குகள் பதிவு செய்யப்பட்டுள்ளன?”
