THE MR.JUSTICE N.RAMESH CRL OP No. 24058 of 2026 CNR: {HCMA011942632026} Dharshan @ Dharshanraj ..Petitioner(s)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 03-11-2026
CORAM
THE MR.JUSTICE N.RAMESH
CRL OP No. 24058 of 2026
CNR: {HCMA011942632026}
Dharshan @ Dharshanraj
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
The State rep by the Inspector of Police
Odiyan Salai Police Station,
Puducherry,
India
(Cr.No.23/2026)
..Respondent(s)
Prayer: This petition is filed under Section 483 of BNSS, 2023, praying to enlarge the petitioner /Accused No.4 on bail in Connection with the Cr.No.23 of 2026. On the file of the respondent police, Odiyansalai Police Station, Puducherry and pass such further or any other order and thus render justice.
For Petitioner(s): Mr.R.N.Kasi Vishwanathan
For Respondent(s): Mr.M.V.Ramachandramurthy,
Additional Public Prosecutor (Puducherry)
ORDER
1. The prayer for bail in this petition under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 was dismissed on 28.08.2026. The petition has remained on board for the reports called for by the orders dated 28.08.2026 and 17.09.2026. The order of 17.09.2026 issued the directions in clauses [a] to [h] of its paragraph 28 and fixed 13.10.2026 for compliance. Three reports have been filed:
i) a status report of the Superintendent of Police (East), Puducherry dated
13.10.2026; ii) a report of the Director, Forensic Science Laboratory, Kirumampakkam dated 01.10.2026; and
iii)a report of the learned Judicial Magistrate-VII, Puducherry dated 08.10.2026, forwarded by the learned Chief Judge, Puducherry.
The Director General of Police, Puducherry has filed no report. The matter was adjourned on 16.10.2026 to today for orders on the reports.
2. On clause [a], the report of the Superintendent of Police discloses that Crl.M.P.No.1472 of 2026, the second petition to cancel a bail that had never been granted, was dismissed; that a petition for re-arrest was then filed as Crl.M.P.No.1620 of 2026 and allowed by the learned Special Judge on 05.10.2026; that the first accused was re-arrested on 06.10.2026 after grounds of arrest were furnished, was given in police custody for three days, and was returned to judicial custody on 12.10.2026; that four more persons have been arrayed as accused and two of them arrested; and that on 05.10.2026 the offences were altered to Sections 22(c), 20(b)(ii)(A) and 29 read with Section 8(c) of the Act and Section 77 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of
Children) Act, 2015. The re-arrest is the first step taken in the direction this Court pointed out on 28.08.2026. It came eight months after 07.02.2026, and only after the order of 17.09.2026. The second accused, who was at liberty on a bond from 09.02.2026, who was served with notice in both petitions and with the grounds of arrest, is reported in a single sentence to be absconding. The report does not say when he ceased to be available or what has been done to find him. The documents which clause [a] required to be produced, the release memoranda, the station and prison records, the bonds, the orders dated 09.02.2026 and 08.07.2026, have not been produced; nor have the orders in Crl.M.P.Nos.1472 and 1620 of 2026. In view of the developments since
17.09.2026, I record these lapses and do not pursue them further in this petition.
3. The re-arrest was effected after Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol v. State of Punjab, 2026 INSC 1022, decided on 21.09.2026, in which the Supreme Court held that where a person has been released for breach of Article 22(1) of the Constitution, an application for his custody may be moved only after the grounds of arrest are furnished, must state the reasons for re-arrest and the explanation for the earlier omission, and must carry the endorsement of the immediate superior authority, who “shall hand over the investigation of the case to another officer, further directing departmental enquiry for such a serious lapse.” The report is silent on whether any of this was done. I say nothing on the legality of the re-arrest, which is for the first accused to raise on its own footing; but the procedure laid down in that decision must now be part of the standing instructions of the force, and the direction to the Director General of Police below is framed accordingly.
4. On clause [b], the explanation offered for the two weights is this: on 17.02.2026 a Sub-Inspector and a Special Grade Assistant Sub-Inspector went to the Laboratory and had an Expert there weigh the stamps “on a two decimal weighing machine”, which gave 0.07 gram for ten and 0.03 gram for four; two undated photographs of paper squares on a pocket scale are enclosed. The Director of the Laboratory, answering clause [c], states that the stamps were received under seal on 09.02.2026, were weighed once, on 12.03.2026, on a laboratory balance by the Analyst named, each stamp weighing 0.0113 gram, and that “the weight was not furnished otherwise than by a report of this Laboratory.” The two accounts cannot both be true. One of them, each made to this Court by a responsible public officer, is not correct. If the photographs were taken at the Laboratory on 17.02.2026, sealed exhibits were opened at the instance of police officers three weeks before analysis; if they were not, the sworn account of that weighing is untrue. I do not decide which. The weight of the contraband and the integrity of the exhibits are questions for the trial, and the Special Court will have both accounts before it. I record the contradiction so that it is not lost sight of, and leave it there.
5. Two further matters are recorded. The Laboratory’s report of analysis dated
23.03.2026 omitted the weight, though the stamps had been weighed on 12.03.2026; the weight reached the Court only on 06.05.2026, and the alteration to a commercial quantity followed on 12.05.2026. In a case under this Act the weight is the fact on which the offence, the sentence and the bail turn, and a report of analysis must state it. Secondly, Lysergide is a psychotropic substance in the Schedule to the Act, and a contravention in relation to it is punishable under Section 22, not under Section 20, which deals with cannabis. From 06.02.2026 to 05.10.2026 this case was registered, charge-sheeted and defended in two courts under Section 20(b)(ii) as if the stamps were ganja. What follows from that is for the Special Court.
6. Clause [c] has been complied with. On the Laboratory’s figure the quantity is commercial, and the liberty under clause [d] stands as given. Clause [e] called for nothing to be reported.
On clause [f], the report of the learned Judicial Magistrate-VII has been received; it is a careful and candid account of the course he took on 07.02.2026 and of his present view, and no further order is called for on it. The question left open in paragraph 26 of the order of 17.09.2026 remains open. Nothing in this order is a finding against the learned Magistrate. On clause [h], the learned Chief Judge’s letter does not expressly confirm the circulation directed; I assume it has been done.
7. Clause [g] was addressed to the Director General of Police. It required him to issue standing instructions to all police stations in the Union Territory on the furnishing of written grounds of arrest in conformity with Mihir Rajesh Shah
v. State of Maharashtra, (2026) 1 SCC 500, and to review the cases under the Act in which arrests were made on and after 06.11.2025 and report the outcome. He has filed nothing. Paragraph 12 of the Superintendent of Police’s report states on his behalf that he “has circulated to all the Police Stations of all cadre a standard operating procedure” and “has reviewed all the cases … and ensured the mandatory constitutional requirement … except the case before this Hon’ble Court.” The document enclosed is not his. It is Standard Operating Procedure No.450/OW/DIGP(L&O)/2026 dated 12.10.2026, issued and signed by the Deputy Inspector General of Police and addressed, among others, to the Director General of Police himself. Its paragraph 11 says the arresting officer “may follow the protocol”; its paragraph 13 declares it “exclusively for the internal smooth functioning of the Police Department”; and it makes no reference to Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol (cited supra), decided three weeks earlier and directed by the Supreme Court to be circulated to the Directors General of Police of all Union Territories. Of the review there is the one sentence quoted: no number of cases, no method, no list, no action taken, and an assurance that the only lapse in the Union Territory since 06.11.2025 is the one this Court has already found. I am unable to accept that any review has been conducted.
8. A direction of this Court to a named authority is to be complied with by that authority and reported by him on his own affidavit, not through a paragraph in a subordinate’s report describing another officer’s instrument. The order was communicated to the Director General of Police by the Registry. His subordinates acted on it, citing its number and date. He filed no affidavit, sought no time, and applied for no modification. The only instrument produced was issued the day before the compliance date, by another officer, under a disclaimer confining it to internal use. On the material before me the non-compliance is deliberate. I record my strong disapproval of the manner in which the head of the police force of the Union Territory has treated a direction of this Court. A direction of this Court is not a request. Wilful disobedience of it is civil contempt within the meaning of Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, which this Court, as a court of record, has the power under Article 215 of the Constitution to punish.
I do not initiate that proceeding today, because the Director General of Police has not been heard. He /She will have one opportunity to comply and to explain on his/her own affidavit why he did not comply by 13.10.2026. Whether the matter rests there will be decided when that affidavit is before me.
9. I do not propose to issue further directions on the matters recorded in paragraphs 2 to 6. The developments since 17.09.2026 have overtaken some of them, and the rest belong to the trial. What this one case shows, however, may be shortly stated, because it is the reason for the directions that follow. The two men from whom the entire contraband was seized were set free the day after their arrest because the grounds were not reduced to writing; nothing was done to cure it for seven months, and when something was done it was the wrong thing, twice; the right course was taken only after two orders of this Court, by which time one of the two had absconded. The case was run under the provision for cannabis. The weight rests on a report that omitted it, and the police account of a different weight is contradicted by the Laboratory. A direction to the head of the force was answered by a subordinate’s assurance that all is well elsewhere. These are failures of elementary discipline at every stage of an investigation which the police themselves describe as one into a chain of suppliers of LSD and ganja to students and tourists across three States. The Supreme Court has said in Ankush Vipan Kapoor v. National Investigation Agency, 2024 INSC 986 that Article 47 casts on the State a duty in this field and that “the State has a responsibility to address the root causes of this predicament and develop effective intervention strategies.” It is not the function of this Court in a bail petition to supervise the policing of the Union Territory. But two things lie beyond this case and within the proper concern of this Court: that the police force of the Union Territory be compelled, by instructions that bind it, to furnish the grounds of arrest in writing in every case as the Constitution requires; and that the Government state what it is doing to prevent the abuse of drugs and to prosecute those who trade in them. The record of this case entitles this Court to ask. I am given to understand from material in the public domain that a State-level committee of the Narco-Coordination Centre chaired by the Chief Secretary exists and met on 30.06.2026, that an Anti-Drug Action Plan for 2026 to 2029 was placed before it, and that the scheme contemplates an Anti-Narcotics Task Force in every Union Territory. I treat none of that as established; it is for the Government to state.
10. A direction cannot be issued to an authority who is not before the Court.
1. The Director General of Police, Puducherry; and 2. The Chief Secretary, Government of Puducherry are therefore suo motu impleaded as the second and the third respondents to this petition, for the limited purpose of receiving and complying with the directions that follow, and the Registry shall carry out the amendment. The directions are administrative in character and touch neither the merits of the accusation nor the liberty of any accused. Liberty is reserved to them to apply for modification.
11. There will be the following directions.
[a] The second respondent, the Director General of Police, Puducherry, shall, within two weeks, issue over his own signature standing instructions binding on every police station and unit in the Union Territory, in the terms of clause [g] of the order dated 17.09.2026 and in conformity with Mihir Rajesh Shah (cited supra) and paragraphs 24 to 25.1 of Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol (cited supra), providing in particular: that the grounds of arrest shall be furnished to every arrested person in writing, in a language he understands, upon arrest where the material is already with the police and in no case later than two hours before his production for remand; that an arrest memo or intimation of arrest is not a substitute for them; that the acknowledgment of the arrested person shall be kept in the case records and placed before the Magistrate with the remand papers; that where a person has been released for breach of Article 22(1), no application for his custody shall be moved except after furnishing the grounds, with the endorsement of the immediate superior authority, who shall transfer the investigation and direct a departmental enquiry; and that failure to furnish written grounds of arrest shall be treated as a dereliction of duty attracting departmental proceedings against the officer concerned. He shall, within three weeks, file his own affidavit producing those instructions and stating:
(i) the review directed by clause [g], with the number of cases under the Act and of arrests since 06.11.2025, the officer who conducted it and the method, the cases in which grounds were found not to have been furnished in writing, and the action taken in each;
(ii) whether any departmental proceeding has been initiated in respect of the arrests of 06.02.2026 and 07.02.2026 in this case;
(iii) the training given or proposed to officers empowered to arrest; and
(iv) why clause [g] was not complied with and reported upon by him personally on or before 13.10.2026.
[b] The third respondent, the Chief Secretary, Government of Puducherry, shall within four weeks file an affidavit stating: (i) whether the State-level committee of the Narco-Coordination Centre has been constituted, when it last met and what it decided, with the Anti-Drug Action Plan for 2026 to 2029 if adopted; (ii) whether an Anti-Narcotics
Task Force or any other separate and specialised wing exists in the Union Territory for the prevention, detection and investigation of offences under the Act, and if so its date of constitution, the rank of its head, its sanctioned and present strength, and whether it has a cell for financial investigation and for action under Chapter V-A of the Act; (iii) whether a designated panel of prosecutors exists for such cases, and the number of Special Courts; (iv) for each year from 2022 to 2026, the cases registered under the Act, the quantity of each substance seized, the persons arrested, the final reports filed within the statutory period, the trials concluded with convictions and acquittals, the cases pending with year of institution, and the detentions ordered under the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988; (v) the samples received by the Forensic Science Laboratory in such cases each year, the average time taken to report, and the sanctioned and present strength of its Chemical Sciences Division; (vi) the measures taken in educational institutions and places frequented by tourists, and the facilities for treatment and de-addiction; and (vii) the steps the Government proposes in the light of this order.
12. The affidavits shall be filed within the time stated against each, and in any event on or before 01.12.2026. The Registry shall communicate a copy of this order forthwith to the Chief Secretary, Government of Puducherry, the Director General of Police, Puducherry, the Superintendent of Police (East), Puducherry, the Inspector of Police, Odiansalai Police Station, the Director, Forensic Science Laboratory, Kirumampakkam, the learned Chief Judge, Puducherry, the
Special Court for NDPS Act, Puducherry and the Public Prosecutor, Puducherry.
13. The observations in this order on the material gathered in the investigation, the weight of the contraband and the exhibits are prima facie, confined to the matters dealt with here, and shall not influence the Special Court at any stage of the trial. Nothing in it is a finding on the personal culpability of any officer, each of whom is entitled to be heard in any proceeding that may follow.
14. Post the matter on [04.12.2026] under the caption “For Reporting Compliance”.
03-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
GBI
To
1.The State rep by the Inspector of Police
Odiyan Salai Police Station,
Puducherry,
India
2.The Director General of Police, Puducherry.
3.The Chief Secretary, Government of Puducherry,
4.The Public Prosecutor, High Court of Madras.
N.RAMESH, J.
GBI
CRL OP No. 24058 of 2026
03-11-2026

FacebookTwitterEmailBloggerGmailLinkedInWhatsAppPinterestTumblrShare

You may also like...

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com
Exit mobile version