These intermediaries say that they have been left out of the recent clarification by the government and that they will continue their legal battle across high courts. The main
Enjoy seamless experience on APP
We’re 10x faster on APP
Read on App
GST: Not all intermediaries out of the woods, will continue legal tussle against government
These intermediaries say that they have been left out of the recent clarification by the government and that they will continue their legal battle across high courts. The main contention for these companies is that they have been slapped with GST …
By Sachin Dave, ET BureauSep 25, 2021, 09:55 AM IST3
The legal battle over goods and services tax on intermediaries is far from over despite a recent clarification by the government, as some exporters, some IT-enabled services providers, and hospitality and travel companies are set to continue their challenge on the constitutionality of the indirect tax on the services they export.
These intermediaries say that they have been left out of the recent clarification by the government and that they will continue their legal battle across high courts. The main contention for these companies is that they have been slapped with GST on services that makes them uncompetitive globally.
Must-read stories from the world of tech & startups, delivered to your inbox.
Enter your email id
We hate spam more than you do
The government has said that services outsourced to India or carried out in the country for foreign entities will not be treated as intermediary services, and hence not face 18% GST. The clarification has come as a huge relief for the country’s $180 billion technology sector.
But, according to tax experts, the recent clarification doesn’t cover about 100,000 intermediaries who were the first to be hit by the decision to slap this GST.
The tax department was holding back tax refunds of IT companies too, and the recent clarification, in essence, merely says this money should be paid back — but only to IT companies.
“The circular doesn’t provide any clarification on the core issue of place of provision of intermediary services that has put the Indian service exporters in trouble. The controversy can be resolved by making certain amendments as per the recommendation of the Rajya Sabha select committee report. Alternatively, a judicial review could be undertaken to settle the issue,” said Abhishek A Rastogi, partner at law firm Khaitan & Co.
Many intermediaries had approached courts and challenged the government’s stand to levy GST on them.
One of the companies which is terming its business as an export of service and seeking exemption from GST is a Mumbai-based entity. It imports large machineries worth millions of dollars and sells those to some of the largest companies in India.
This company claims that it provides a “service” to multinational machine manufacturers for a fee. The tax department, however, terms it as an intermediary.
As per current regulations, exports do not attract GST and exporters can also claim refunds of the tax paid on inputs from the revenue department.
This policy is aimed at making Indian goods and services more competitive in the international markets.
But, according to the tax department’s rationale, if an Indian company is merely implementing what is being dictated by a foreign entity, then it is an intermediary and is not exporting any services.
The controversy erupted following a 2018 directive by the Authority of Advance Rulings on GST. The ruling that defined intermediaries said they don’t export.
The indirect tax department had started issuing notices to several IT/ITeS companies demanding up to 18% GST on money received on convertible foreign exchange.
The GST Council, however. said IT companies should not be considered intermediaries.
(Catch all the Business News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)
Download The Economic Times News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.
READ MORE NEWS ON
GSTINDIAIT DEPARTMENTTAXINCOME TAXREFUNS
3 COMMENTS ON THIS STORY
1 day ago
GST is a new Law, ambiguity to avoided at earliest by officials , And user friendly, not l…Read More
1 day ago
The definition of intermediary cannot be subjective. In my view if a service is being prov…Read More
1 day ago
Litigation never ends!!
IT/ITES companies did get a big relief with being moved out of…Read More
Stories of the day
Bhavish Aggarwal’s nightmare: delayed launch of Ola Electric’s booking platform flags long road ahead
9 mins read
From kitchen to cabinet: Bhavish Aggarwal’s relentless hunger to find the perfect recipe with Ola Foods
11 mins read
As fortunes of IRB, India Grid vary, InvITs need more love for Centre’s asset-selling plan to click
10 mins read
Amazon Sunday Offers – Upto 70% off on Clothing, Appliances , Electronics, & More
Australian and Indian business leaders partner for investment opportunities
Indiabulls Housing Finance sells stake worth Rs 251 cr in OakNorth Holdings
BUSINESS NEWS › INDUSTRY › BANKING/FINANCE › FINANCE › GST: NOT ALL INTERMEDIARIES OUT OF THE WOODS, WILL CONTINUE LEGAL TUSSLE AGAINST GOVERNMENT
AutoBanking/FinanceCons. ProductsEnergyRenewablesInd’l Goods/SvsHealthcare/BiotechServicesMedia/EntertainmentTransportationTechTelecomMiscellaneousCSREnvironment
Hot on Web
Narendra Modi Live newsSensex todayMutual funds SIP 2021What are multi asset fundsWhat are balanced mutual fundsGlobal marketsMutual fundsBreaking newsLTC Cash Voucher SchemeSGX NiftySensex LiveIRCTC share priceInfosys share priceRupeeAadhaar CardHow to save Income TaxCurrency ConverterIncome Tax Calculator
In Case you missed it
5G AuctionAmazon IndiaDiesel Price TodayNitin GadkariSony Zee DealAmazon Prime VideoEdelweiss GroupFestive Season SalesTata DigitalVodafone IdeaHDFC BankKirana StoresYes Bank Dish TV DisputeJiopagesAGR duesAuto NewsBanking NewsJio Fiber
More from our network
Pune MirrorBangalore MirrorAhmedabad MirrorItsMyAscentEducation TimesBrand CapitalMumbai MirrorTimes NowIndiatimesमहाराष्ट्र टाइम्सವಿಜಯ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕGo GreenAdAge IndiaEisamayIGN IndiaIamGujaratTimes of IndiaSamayam TamilSamayam TeluguMiss KyraBombay TimesFilmipopGames AppMX PlayerNewspaper SubscriptionTimes PrimeColombia Ads and PublishingNBT Gold PodcastEi Samay Gold PodcastMX ShareKaro AppMX TakaTak App
Download ET APP
Follow us on
Copyright © 2021 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. For reprint rights:
Times Syndication Service